Functional significance of the microstructural detail of the primate dentino-enamel junction: a possible example of exaptation

In primate teeth, the dentino-enamel junction (DEJ) exhibits a scalloped appearance, the functional importance of which has been the subject of various suggestions and speculations. Simplified finite-element (FE) models of DEJ microanatomy were created, both in 2D and 3D, and their biomechanical behavior was tested and compared. Consistently, the models with the scalloped DEJ, although having higher maximum tensile stresses than the straight DEJ models, showed discontinuous concentrations of stress. In straight DEJ models, tensile stresses act at the DEJ over continuous areas in a direction, which would push the two tissues apart, thus leading to delamination of the DEJ. Perhaps even more important, in the scallop model, the net-compression towards the DEJ was consistently higher than net-tension away from it. As a consequence, dentine and enamel would be pushed towards each other during loading (i.e., during mastication). These findings suggest that the scalloped nature of the DEJ confers a biomechanical advantage to the integrity of the tooth during mastication. Furthermore, there exists a correlation between pronounced prism decussation and scallop magnitude, suggesting that scallops may have been selected for in response to high bite forces. However, given the equivocal relationship between scallops and presumed bite force across mammalian taxa, we propose that scallops could in fact be exaptations.