Comparison of 13CH3, 13CH2D,and 13CHD2 methyl labeling strategies in proteins

A comparison of three labeling strategies for studies involving side chain methyl groups in high molecular weight proteins, using ¹³CH₃,¹³CH₂D, and ¹³CHD₂ methyl isotopomers, is presented. For each labeling scheme, ¹H–¹³C pulse sequences that give optimal resolution and sensitivity are identified. Three highly deuterated samples of a 723 residue enzyme, malate synthase G, with ¹³CH₃,¹³CH₂D, and ¹³CHD₂ labeling in Ile δ1 positions, are used to test the pulse sequences experimentally, and a rationalization of each sequence’s performance based on a product operator formalism that focuses on individual transitions is presented. The HMQC pulse sequence has previously been identified as a transverse relaxation optimized experiment for ¹³CH₃-labeled methyl groups attached to macromolecules, and a zero-quantum correlation pulse scheme (¹³CH₃ HZQC) has been developed to further improve resolution in the indirectly detected dimension. We present a modified version of the ¹³CH₃ HZQC sequence that provides improved sensitivity by using the steady-state magnetization of both ¹³C and ¹H spins. The HSQC and HMQC spectra of ¹³CH₂D-labeled methyl groups in malate synthase G are very poorly resolved, but we present a new pulse sequence, ¹³CH₂D TROSY, that exploits cross-correlation effects to record ¹H–¹³C correlation maps with dramatically reduced linewidths in both dimensions. Well-resolved spectra of ¹³CHD₂-labeled methyl groups can be recorded with HSQC or HMQC; a new ¹³CHD₂ HZQC sequence is described that provides improved resolution with no loss in sensitivity in the applications considered here. When spectra recorded on samples prepared with the three isotopomers are compared, it is clear that the ¹³CH₃ labeling strategy is the most beneficial from the perspective of sensitivity (gains ≥2.4 relative to either ¹³CH₂D or ¹³CHD₂ labeling), although excellent resolution can be obtained with any of the isotopomers using the pulse sequences presented here.