Long-term movement of 15N tracers into fine woody debris under chronically elevated N inputs

Two key questions in the study of large-scale C (carbon) and N (nitrogen) cycling in temperate forests are how N cycling in soil detritus controls ecosystem-level retention of elevated N deposition, and whether elevated N deposition is likely to cause increases in C pools. The large C:N ratios in woody detritus make it a potentially important contributor to N retention, if N immobilization increases, and a potentially important contributor to C sequestration, if pool sizes increase. We studied N concentrations, C:N ratios, and pool sizes of N and biomass in fine woody debris (FWD < 5 cm diam.) 12 years into a long-term N-amendment study in two contrasting forests, a naturally-regenerated forest dominated by Quercus spp., and a 63-yr old plantation of Pinus resinosa. We also quantitatively recovered ¹⁵N tracers (originally applied as ¹⁵NH₄ and ¹⁵NO₃) in FWD, eight years following their application in the same study, in both ambient and N-amended plots. We used these data to test predictions of tracer redistributions made by a biogeochemical process model that included ¹⁵N. Results from the N pool-size analysis and the ¹⁵N tracer-recovery analysis indicated that under elevated N inputs of 5 g N m^–2 yr^–1 (as NH₄NO₃) over the decadal time period, only 0.15%–0.76% of the elevated N inputs were recovered in FWD of N-amended plots relative to ambient. Any increase in N immobilization in wood appeared to be minimal, in agreement with model predictions. Under N amendments, pool sizes of C in FWD were not significantly different from ambient, whereas pool sizes of N were marginally higher. Patterns of ¹⁵NH₄ vs. ¹⁵NO₃ recovery, treatment differences, and forest-type differences suggested that plant uptake, rather than detrital immobilization, was the dominant mechanism of ¹⁵N tracer movement into FWD. This result indicates that plant-soil cycling operating over a decadal time scale or longer controls C:N ratios and N pool sizes in woody debris.