Altered torquoselectivity of fluorine in the iron-tricarbonyl-mediated thermal ring opening of 3-fluorocyclobutene: a density-functional exploration

There are eight possible pathways for the iron-tricarbonyl-assisted thermal electrocyclic ring opening of fluorocyclobutene due to variations in the orientation of the binding of Fe(CO)₃ relative to the fluorine substituent (R₁ or R₂), stereoselectivity (conrotatory or disrotatory, i.e., C or D), and the torquoselectivity of fluorine (inward-facing or outward-facing, i.e., in or out). A density functional study revealed that the energetically favored pathway is R₁ Din. Not only is the D mode favored energetically, but the in configuration was observed to be the lowest-lying mode of R₁, despite the general tendency of fluorine substituents to prefer an out configuration. Data on the activation hardness and aromaticity indices such as BAC and HOMA lead to the same conclusion. However, the R₂ mode surprisingly shows no particular preference for either the Cout or the Dout pathway (i.e., the R₂ mode shows less stereoselectivity than R₁). This behavior occurs due to the influences of both the fluorine substituent and metal coordination. Also, the geminal bond orbitals σ(C–F) and σ*(C–F) appear to participate in ring opening, given the excellent correlation of ?BE with the activation barrier of the transition state.