Testing generalizations about latitudinal variation in reproduction and recruitment patterns with sicyoniid and caridean shrimp species

Summary

Study of latitudinal variation in seasonality of reproduction and recruitment of benthic marine invertebrates is useful in generating and testing hypotheses about causal factors acting on reproduction such as temperature and larval food supply that might be altered by changes in world climate. Analysis of latitudinal variation in reproductive patterns might be made with comparisons (a) among species with a common phylogenetic history from different latitudes and habitats and (b) among phylogenetically different taxa from the same location. Hypotheses on variation of reproductive seasonality with latitude are tested here with results of a study on nine species of caridean and two species of sicyoniid shrimp sampled from a tropical seagrass meadow in Puerto Rico. Breeding condition was determined by the presence or absence of incubated embryos (carideans) and the state of ovarian development in both carideans and sicyoniids. Recruitment was estimated from the percentage of individuals of monthly population samples in the juvenile size classes. Comparison of reproductive patterns among tropical, subtropical, and cool temperate Sicyonia spp. supports the paradigm of continuous reproduction in the tropics with increased restriction of breeding season with an increase in latitude. A greater intensity of breeding effort appears to accompany the shorter breeding period associated with an increase in latitude. At the tropical site most females of all caridean species carried embryos during all months of the year. With the onset of sexual maturity, caridean females produced consecutive broods for the rest of their relatively short (< 6 month) life span. In both sicyoniid and caridean species, recruitment occurred throughout the year but was highly variable, i.e., episodic rather than truly continuous or seasonal. Patterns of recruitment were highly concordant among but not between sicyoniid and caridean species, indicating that different sets of environmental factors controlled recruitment in the two groups. It is suggested that simultaneous study of adult reproduction and larval ecology is necessary to understand patterns of reproduction and recruitment. Coordinated effort on a global scale in studying latitudinal variation in reproduction and recruitment is suggested in order to predict the consequences of climate change on commercially and ecologically important marine invertebrate species.