Decades of atmospheric deposition have not resulted in widespread phosphorus limitation or saturation of tree demand for nitrogen in southern New England

It is commonly assumed that nitrogen (N) is the primary mineral resource limiting the productivity of temperate forests. Sustained inputs of N via atmospheric deposition are altering the N status of temperate forests raising the possibility that nutrients such as phosphorus (P) are increasingly limiting productivity. The objective of this study was to determine whether P availability limits tree growth alone or in combination with N. This study was conducted in two forest types common throughout the New England landscape of the northeastern United States; in sugar maple and white ash dominated stands growing on base rich parent material characterized by rapid rates of N cycling and high N availability, and in red oak–beech–hemlock dominated stands growing on base-poor parent material characterized by slow rates of N cycling and low N availability. Starting in 2004, N and P were added to replicate plots in each forest type in factorial combination at a rate of 150 and 50 kg ha⁻¹ year⁻¹, respectively. Diameter growth rates of all trees >10 cm DBH were measured in 2005 and 2006 using dendrometer bands and converted into units of basal area increment (BAI) and wood production. Following 2 years of fertilization, basal area increment in the sugar maple–white ash forests remained strongly N limited. Fertilization with P did not significantly increase BAI alone, although both N and P fertilization tended (P < 0.10) to increase diameter growth in white ash. Wood production in the N-fertilized plots increased by 100 g C m⁻² year⁻¹, roughly doubling production in the non-fertilized plots. In the red oak–beech–hemlock stands, there was no overall effect of N or P fertilization on BAI or wood production because BAI in some species was stimulated by fertilization with N alone (e.g., black cherry, red oak), while in other species BAI was unaffected (e.g., red maple, beech) or negatively affected by fertilization with N or P (e.g., eastern hemlock). Given that BAI in several tree species responded to fertilization with N alone and that only one species responded to P fertilization once N was added, this study suggests that decades of atmospheric N deposition have not (yet) resulted in widespread P limitation or saturation of tree demand for N.