Effects of Long-Term Starvation on a Host Bivalve (Codakia orbicularis,Lucinidae) and Its Symbiont Population

The bivalve Codakia orbicularis, hosting sulfur-oxidizing gill endosymbionts, was starved (in artificial seawater filtered through a 0.22-μm-pore-size membrane) for a long-term experiment (4 months). The effects of starvation were observed using transmission electron microscopy, fluorescence in situ hybridization and catalyzed reporter deposition (CARD-FISH), and flow cytometry to monitor the anatomical and physiological modifications in the gill organization of the host and in the symbiotic population housed in bacteriocytes. The abundance of the symbiotic population decreased through starvation, with a loss of one-third of the bacterial population each month, as shown by CARD-FISH. At the same time, flow cytometry revealed significant changes in the physiology of symbiotic cells, with a decrease in cell size and modifications to the nucleic acid content, while most of the symbionts maintained a high respiratory activity (measured using the 5-cyano-2,3-ditolyl tetrazolium chloride method). Progressively, the number of symbiont subpopulations was reduced, and the subsequent multigenomic state, characteristic of this symbiont in freshly collected clams, turned into one and five equivalent genome copies for the two remaining subpopulations after 3 months. Concomitant structural modifications appeared in the gill organization. Lysosymes became visible in the bacteriocytes, while large symbionts disappeared, and bacteriocytes were gradually replaced by granule cells throughout the entire lateral zone. Those data suggested that host survival under these starvation conditions was linked to symbiont digestion as the main nutritional source.The entire marine Lucinidae family, found in a wide range of sulfidic habitats, lives in association with chemoautotrophic sulfide-oxidizing bacterial symbionts, generally hosted in the gills of the bivalve. Lucinids are usually found in shallow water, such as intertidal mud or seagrasses (4, 53), in deeper water, e.g., Bathyaustriella thionipta (30), and in deep oceans at a 2,000-m depth, i.e., Lucinoma kazani (21, 55). The chemoautotrophic endosymbionts involved in such relationships are always localized inside specialized cells called bacteriocytes, and they have been found in several genera of the Lucinidae family, such as Codakia (4, 28), Loripes (39, 43), Lucina, and Lucinoma (17). Sulfur granules inside the symbiont cytoplasm have been demonstrated in most of the investigated species. The intracellular symbionts take energy from the oxidation of reduced sulfur compounds (27, 56, 59) and synthesize organic molecules by CO₂ fixation in a Calvin-Benson cycle, translocated to the host (18). This relationship between the host and its symbionts represents the autotrophic pathway for host nutrition (27). It has also been suggested that in symbiotic bivalves, intracellular digestion of the symbionts may be a nutrient source for the host, based on studies of hydrothermal vent and shallow water bivalves (6, 26, 39).The relative importance of the autotrophic versus heterotrophic nutritional pathway can be estimated by measuring the carbon isotope (δ-¹³C) ratios in the host tissue. Measuring this δ-¹³C ratio on a wide range of invertebrates suggested that bivalves, including members of the Lucinidae, that live in reduced sediment may obtain a significant proportion of their organic carbon from chemoautotrophic endosymbionts (4, 10, 51, 52, 57). This suggestion was in agreement with the reduced functional digestive system previously described for the Lucinidae family (2, 53). Structural and morphological studies of gills of a few lucinids (belonging to the genera Lucina and Lucinoma) strongly suggested that symbionts play an important role in host nutrition since they occupy about 30% of the gill tissue and produce most of the host energy (17). Nevertheless, an alternative pathway for feeding, i.e., heterotrophic particulate feeding, could occur in some of the lucinid bivalves, since diatoms were found in the stomach of some lucinids (57). Duplessis et al. (22) showed that particulate feeding could be an important part of the nutritional strategy in symbiont-bearing Lucinoma, as opposed to the anatomical features that gave the impression that this bivalve relied only on symbiont nutrition.In natural habitats, chemoautotrophic bivalves live at the interface between an anoxic sulfide-generating zone and water column oxygenated sediment. However, even if they are not close to a vent, these symbiotic organisms often have to deal with environments that are periodically depleted of oxygen (5, 12) and with extremely low sulfide concentration (13, 15, 16). These natural environmental variations lead to annual and seasonal changes in the δ-¹³C ratio, as observed for some thyasirid species (13, 14). This δ-¹³C ratio variation may be assumed to correspond to the capability of the host to rely on both autotrophic and heterotrophic pathways, and the preponderance of one pathway versus the other in the mixotrophic diet has been considered to be the way in which these organisms deal with changes in the chemical composition of their environment.Apart from the decrease in symbiont abundance suggested by transmission electron microscopy (TEM) analysis and a decrease in sulfur and protein content in the gill tissue of thyasirids (20, 38, 40), little is known about the physiological status of these symbionts and the changes undergone by the symbiotic population of starved bivalves. A previous study of the population was carried out under natural conditions with Codakia orbicularis, a chemoautotrophic bivalve. This tropical bivalve lives in shallow-water sediment among the roots of seagrasses (Thalassia testudinum) (1). Like all lucinids studied so far, it is associated with sulfur-oxidizing symbionts (4, 27, 28) containing elemental sulfur in their cytoplasm (42). The bacterial symbiont of C. orbicularis, environmentally transmitted to the host (31), belongs to a single taxonomic group (Gammaproteobacteria) (25) and is shared by several other tropical lucinids (24, 25, 34, 35). Only a few data are available on the physiology of this symbiont. It was characterized by the presence of Rubisco and ATP sulfurylase enzymes and a δ-¹³C ratio typical of chemoautotrophic bivalves (4). Unlike other related thyasirids tested for nitrate respiration even under oxygenated conditions (37), the symbionts of C. orbicularis use oxygen as the primary electron acceptor (23). Initial investigations of the population of Codakia orbicularis'' symbiont revealed that the symbiotic population hosted by freshly collected individuals contained a high proportion of large bacterial cells containing multiple copies of their genome, typical of actively growing cells, despite the absence of dividing cells (11). It was assumed that the host could maintain a pure culture of the symbiont inside the bacteriocytes by regulating the entry and growth of newly recruited symbionts from sediment and probably regulating symbiont densities by host digestion (11).This study was undertaken to investigate the dynamics of the symbiotic population hosted by C. orbicularis under experimental conditions based on long-term starvation of bivalves, i.e., incubated without planktonic food. We set out the ultrastructural, structural, and physiological changes that occurred in the symbiont population by examining the host gill sections using TEM and fluorescence in situ hybridization and catalyzed reporter deposition (CARD-FISH). A purified fraction of gill endosymbionts was analyzed by flow cytometry (FCM) to investigate the nucleic acid content and cell size of symbionts and by using the 5-cyano-2,3-ditolyl tetrazolium chloride (CTC) method and epifluorescence microscopy to detect the respiratory activity of symbionts. The modifications induced by host starvation in the symbiotic population are described for the period of long-term starvation.