Change in Apoplastic Aluminum during the Initial Growth Response to Aluminum by Roots of a Tolerant Maize Variety

Root elongation, hematoxylin staining, and changes in the ultrastructure of root-tip cells of an Al-tolerant maize variety (Zea mays L. C 525 M) exposed to nutrient solutions with 20 μm Al (2.1 μm Al³⁺ activity) for 0, 4, and 24 h were investigated in relation to the subcellular distribution of Al using scanning transmission electron microscopy and energy-dispersive x-ray microanalysis on samples fixed by different methods. Inhibition of root-elongation rates, hematoxylin staining, cell wall thickening, and disturbance of the distribution of pyroantimoniate-stainable cations, mainly Ca, was observed only after 4 and not after 24 h of exposure to Al. The occurrence of these transient, toxic Al effects on root elongation and in cell walls was accompanied by the presence of solid Al-P deposits in the walls. Whereas no Al was detectable in cell walls after 24 h, an increase of vacuolar Al was observed after 4 h of exposure. After 24 h, a higher amount of electron-dense deposits containing Al and P or Si was observed in the vacuoles. These results indicate that in this tropical maize variety, tolerance mechanisms that cause a change in apoplastic Al must be active. Our data support the hypothesis that in Al-tolerant plants, Al can rapidly cross the plasma membrane; these data clearly contradict the former conclusions that Al mainly accumulates in the apoplast and enters the symplast only after severe cell damage has occurred.It is largely recognized that root tips are the primary site of Al-induced injury in plants (Ryan et al., 1993). The accumulation of Al in root tips has been found to be significantly correlated with root-growth inhibition in maize (Zea mays L.) varieties differing in Al tolerance (Llugany, 1994; Llugany et al., 1994). In Al-sensitive maize plants an inhibition of root elongation has been observed after only 30 min of exposure to Al (Llugany et al., 1995). Such a short response time, in addition to the common belief (Kochian, 1995) that Al accumulates mainly in the apoplast and crosses the plasma membrane slowly, has led to the hypothesis that Al-induced inhibition of root elongation may be caused by toxicity mechanisms that occur in the apoplast (Rengel, 1990, 1996; Horst, 1995) and that there is no need for Al to enter the symplast to cause primary toxicity effects (Rengel, 1992). However, investigations using the highly Al-sensitive technique of secondary ion MS have shown that significant Al concentrations accumulate in the symplast of root-tip cells of soybean plants after only 30 min of exposure to Al (Lazof et al., 1994, 1996). Recent experiments on giant algae (Chara corallina) cells, where cell walls were separated from the cells by microsurgery, have also shown that Al uptake across the plasmalemma may be linear and occurs without delay (Rengel and Reid, 1997). These investigations support the view that symplastic phytotoxicity mechanisms may also be responsible for Al-induced inhibition of root elongation after short exposure times (Kochian, 1995).More information on the subcellular distribution of Al in root tips would help to establish both the relative importance of apoplastic and symplastic sites in the Al-toxicity syndrome and the role of Al compartmentation in Al resistance or tolerance. Unfortunately, ultrastructural investigations under environmentally realistic growth conditions that relate the subcellular localization of Al in root tips to root growth in Al-tolerant varieties are scarce (Delhaize et al., 1993). Major difficulties for such an approach are the low sensitivity of electron probe x-ray microanalysis for Al determination (Lazof et al., 1994, 1997) and the poor visual distinction of subcellular structures in freeze-dried samples, in combination with the extremely low Al tissue concentrations, which have been shown to cause inhibition of root elongation (Lazof et al., 1994, 1996).Using a highly sensitive monitoring technique for root growth, we have previously shown that 20 μm Al (2.1 μm Al³⁺ activity) causes a significant decrease in the relative root-elongation rate in the Al-tolerant maize var C 525 M after 112 min of exposure, whereas after 24 h the relative elongation rate did not differ from that of the controls (Llugany et al., 1995). In this paper we report results on the changes in the subcellular distribution of Al in root tips during the initial root-growth response (0–24 h) of var C 525 M exposed to 20 μm Al (2.1 μm Al³⁺ activity). Hematoxylin staining, ultrastructural observations, and EDXMA were performed on root tips after 0, 4, and 24 h of exposure of plants to control or Al-containing nutrient solutions to detect a possible relationship between changes in subcellular Al compartmentation and ultrastructural alterations, which may explain why, after a transient inhibition, the root-elongation rate recovers during the initial 24 h of exposure to Al. EDXMA with scanning TEM on glutaraldehyde-fixed, PA-stained, and freeze-substituted samples were performed. Although these techniques only allow a semiquantitative estimation of mineral contents, the better visual resolution obtained results in more reliable data on the subcellular localization than EDXMA with SEM on freeze-dried or frozen-hydrated bulk specimens (Van Steveninck and Van Steveninck, 1991).