Comparison of partial excision with simple section of the transverse carpal ligament in the treatment of carpal tunnel syndrome

In the surgical treatment of carpal tunnel syndrome, debate has commonly focused on whether decompression should be performed by open or blind techniques. Contrarily, the goal of the present study was to determine whether instead of simple section, partial excision of the transverse carpal ligament has contributed to better results. Because complete healing of the transverse carpal ligament observed during reoperations has been reported elsewhere, the charts of 75 carpal tunnel syndrome patients who had been treated with open technique at Dokuz Eylül University were reviewed. Statistical analysis was performed using the Fisher's exact test and Student's t test when appropriate. Thirty-five patients had been treated with simple section of the transverse carpal ligament, whereas 40 had been treated with partial excision. Internal neurolysis was also performed in 19 of the patients, 11 of whom were treated with partial excision. The average follow-up time was 3.8 years. The comparisons regarding the overall operative outcomes did not show any significant difference between the two different techniques of releasing the transverse carpal ligament. In patients treated without neurolysis, results of partial excision of the transverse carpal ligament improved when compared with those of simple section, but this superiority was not statistically significant. There seemed to be statistically higher reoperation rates and worse outcomes after neurolysis (p < 0.05). Reoperation was required in eight patients (11 percent). Five of the patients who underwent reoperation had initially been treated with partial excision and neurolysis, whereas two had been treated with simple section and neurolysis. Another patient who had undergone reoperation had initially undergone only simple section. The mean time to return to work or daily activities did not differ between the types of applied technique for releasing the transverse carpal ligament. However, neurolysis lengthened these periods significantly when performed (p < 0.05). In the present study, partial excision of the transverse carpal ligament without adding neurolysis offered relatively better results than simple section. Verification of this finding endoscopically, if applicable, may improve the success rate of surgical therapy in patients with carpal tunnel syndrome.