Past hybridization between Quercus macrocarpa and Quercus gambelii

Introgression between two allopatric species,Quercus macrocarpa andQ. gambelii, has been observed in two separate locations: northeastern New Mexico and the Black Hills of western South Dakota and adjacent Wyoming. The probability that this introgression is the result of long-range pollination appears remote. Presumably these two species hybridized during a period of past sympatric association. Further indication of past sympatry in the Black Hills is the presence of a common species of obligate parasite, i.e., wasp(Cynips insulensis) onQ. gambelii in the Rocky Mountains and onQ. macrocarpa of the Black Hills. The hybrid oaks in New Mexico probably reflect a westward migration ofQ. macrocarpa during pluvial periods of the Pleistocene.Quercus gambelii most likely reached the Black Hills during the warmer postglacial hypsithermal era. The hybridization reported here may reflect secondary sympatry, i.e., sympatric occurrence after the species, or their ancestors, became geographically separated.