Swelling of spinach chloroplasts induced by HCHO and KMnO4, an effect partially hidden by the wide size range of chloroplasts

Both KMnO₄ and HCHO in concentrations used for fixation forelectron microscopy induce pronounced swelling of spinach chloroplasts.However, since electron microscopy samples small numbers, itis possible to overlook the swelling effect because the sizerange of the swollen chloroplasts can overlap the extremelywide range of chloroplasts in living mesophyll cells. HCHO fixesspinach chloroplasts only after 16 hr incubation, as verifiedby failure of the chloroplaststo swell when subsequently washedwith water. However, the HCHO treatment fails to prevent aninitial swelling and KMnO₄ further swells chloroplasts pre-fixedwith HCHO. Spinach chloroplasts in vivo measured in face area27.7 0.06 µ² mean value, 23.8 µ² mode value, range6.2 to 102.9 µ², and their distribution is skewed so thatthe coefficient of skewness is 0.15. Chloroplasts isolated directlyinto phosphate buffered 4% HCHO after 24 hrs measured in facearea 58.2 µ² mean value, 46.5 µ² mode value, range22 to 121 µ², and the coefficient of skewness increasedto 0.24. When such chloroplasts were additionally treated withphosphate buffered 2.8 % KMnO₄ the spinach chloroplasts measuredin facearea 96.4 1.40 µ² mean value, 86.1 µ² modevalue, range22 to 203 µ², and the coefficient of skewnessunchanged at 0.24. Volumes of spinach chloroplasts isolatedin NaCl as reported in the literature approach the volumes ofchloroplasts swollen by HCHO and KMnO₄. Some problems concerningsampling difficulties because of wide size ranges and skeweddistributions are discussed. ¹ Present address: Department of Agriculture, Bangkhen ExperimentStation, Bangkok, Thailand. ² Present address: Department of Biology, Wright State University,Dayton, Ohio 45431 U.S.A.