BREEDING SUCCESS IN SOME AFRICAN EAGLES RELATED TO THEORIES ABOUT SIBLING AGGRESSION AND ITS EFFECTS

Brown, L. H., Gargett, V. & Steyn, P. 1977. Breeding success in some African Eagles related to theories about sibling aggression and its effects. Ostrich 48:65-71. Previous explanations for fatal inter-sibling strife in eagles (lack of food, extra aggressiveness which enhances survival, and an expression of the innate aggressiveness or territoriality of raptors) can not be supported by recent evidence. The latest theory, that the second egg acts as a “reserve”, is examined. If so, eagles normally laying two eggs should have better reproductive success than eagles laying a single egg. However there was no significant difference between the mean reproductive success of five African eagle species that lay two eggs and that of five African eagle species laying one egg. Even excluding inequalities due to sample size, and other factors, the overall finding is the same. In Verreaux's Eagle Aquila verreauxi for which the largest number of records is available there was a significantly higher total loss in clutches recorded as c/l than in c/2 clutches, but the reasons for the laying of a one-egg clutch, and its success or failure, have not been investigated. In three out of 120 c/2 the second-laid egg acted as a “reserve”, but in 110 cases the second-laid egg was “wasted”. Direct evidence and a comparison of reproductive success between two-egg and one-egg African eagles does not support the latest theory, therefore inter-sibling strife which effectively reduces the clutch of two to one, is still inexplicable.