Methods of classifying nemerteans: an assessment

Phenetic, cladistic and phyletic methods of classifying animals are discussed with particular reference to nemerteans. It is concluded that phenetic (numerical) taxonomy is particularly inapplicable to any group of invertebrates for which well defined character differences are relatively few, whilst both the phenetic and cladistic methods fail through their fundamental assumption that convergent evolution is a rare occurrence. Terrestrial and freshwater nemerteans especially demonstrate convergent evolution in many ways; cladistic classifications proposed for these animals are therefore untenable. Convergence is shown to be a common occurrence in other nemerteans also. It is concluded that because the traditional phyletic approach does not implicitly assume that resemblances between organisms are more likely to be due to common ancestry than to convergence, it is far more likely to reveal true evolutionary relationships between taxa.