A comparative study evaluating the dose volume parameters in 3D conformal radiation of left sided whole breast irradiation including regional lymphnodes — a need of resource constrained countries

BackgroundThe purpose of this study was to compare four 3D conformal radiation techniques in treatment of left breast cancer patients.Materials and methodsRadiation was planned for 20 patients to the left breast and regional lymph nodes using four techniques: partially wide tangents, photon-photon mix, photon-electron mix and 30/70 photon-electron mix. All plans were evaluated for internal mammary nodes (IMN) coverage, hotspot and normal tissue constraints.ResultThe 85% of planning target volume (PTV) coverage was lesser for upper IMN than the lower IMN (below the lower border of the clavicular head) for all four techniques. The lower IMN coverage was better for partially wide tangent (80.46%) and photon-photon mix (88.88%). The lowest value of hotspot was seen in the partially wide tangent technique (112.69% ± 1.92). Hotspot is unacceptably high in both photon-electron mix and 30/70 photon-electron mix (> 120%). Left lung mean dose for all techniques on a pair-wise comparison showed no statistical difference. Left lung V20 values for partially wide tangent was 37.56% ± 8.17 and for photon-photon mix it was 40.49% ± 3.36. The mean heart dose with partially wide tangent was 9.43 ± 3.15 Gy and with photon-photon mix it was 10.10 ± 2.70 Gy. The mean heart dose for photon-electron mix was 7.56 ± 1.95 Gy and for 30/70 photon-electron mix it was 7.98 ± 2.16 Gy.ConclusionNo single technique satisfies all the criteria. The decision should be made on a case-by-case basis, considering the anatomy of the patient, availability of electron facilities and setup accuracy and reproducibility.