The segmented urbilateria: a testable scenario

The idea that the last common ancestor of bilaterian animals(Urbilateria) was segmented has been raised recently on evidencecoming from comparative molecular embryology. Leaving asidethe complex debate on the value of genetic evidence, the morphologicaland developmental evidence in favor of a segmented Urbilateriaare discussed in the light of the emerging molecular phylogenyof metazoans. Applying a cladistic character optimization procedureto the question of segmentation is vastly complicated by theproblem of defining without ambiguity what segmentation is andto what taxa this definition applies. An ancestral segmentationmight have undergone many complex derivations in each differentphylum, thus rendering the cladistics approaches problematic.Taking the most general definitions of coelom and segmentationhowever, some remarkably similar patterns are found across thebilaterian tree in the way segments are formed by the posterioraddition of mesodermal segments or somites. Postulating thatthese striking similarities in mesodermal patterns are ancestral,a scenario for the diversification of bilaterians from a metamericancestor is presented. Several types of evolutionary mechanisms(specialization, tagmosis, progenesis) operating on a segmentedancestral body plan would explain the rapid emergence of bodyplans during the Cambrian. We finally propose to test this hypothesisby comparing genes involved in mesodermal segmentation.