Estimating Fundamental Host Range: a Host-Specificity Study of a Potential Biocontrol Agent for Prosopis Species (Leguminosae)

One approach to predicting non-target attack by potential biological control agents is to first describe their fundamental host ranges and then to predict how it will be expressed under postrelease field conditions. In this paper, we illustrate how the fundamental host range can be estimated experimentally by excluding possible limiting factors such as time-dependent effects. The example we use is a host-specificity study of a leaf-tying moth (Gelechiidae: Evippe sp. #1) which was being assessed for the biological control of mesquite (Leguminosae: Prosopis spp.) in Australia. Females oviposited all eggs on plants, mostly into cracks and fissures. First instar larvae leaf-mined and subsequent instars leaf-tied. Oviposition was not host-specific in cage trials, although ten times more eggs were laid on Prosopis than on non-targets. The fundamental host range for initiation of larval feeding was restricted to Prosopis and Leucaena leucocephala which both belong to the same tribe, and the fundamental host range for complete larval development was restricted to Prosopis . We predict that if released in Australia Evippe sp. #1 will only attack Prosopis spp., although low levels of 'indiscriminate' oviposition might occur on other taxa, and might result in initiation of feeding on L. leucocephala .