Phenological and chemical differences among hybrid poplar clones (Salicaceae) varying in resistance to Cryptorhynchus lapathi (L.) (Coleoptera: Curculionidae)

Hybrid poplars with Populus maximowiczii parentage have demonstrated antixenotic resistance against adult poplar-and-willow borers, Cryptorhynchus lapathi (L.) (Coleoptera: Curculionidae), in the summer, and antibiosis against C. lapathi larvae in the spring. We examined phenological and biochemical differences among hybrid poplars with and without P. maximowiczii parentage that are resistant and susceptible, respectively, to C. lapathi, to test the hypotheses that resistance was due to physical hydraulic forces, inadequate nutrition, or abundant secondary metabolites. The hybrids with P. maximowiczii parentage flushed earlier than susceptible hybrids, but no differences were found between hybrids with respect to sap flow or bark moisture content that could explain larval mortality in the spring. Similarly, constitutive levels of nutritive compounds (sitosterol, nitrogen, linoleic and linolenic acids, and carbohydrates) were lower or not different in the most susceptible hybrid TN 302-9. Thus, all hybrids appear to be nutritionally sound. TN 302-9 contained the highest constitutive levels of condensed tannins and catechin, but overall phenolic glycoside levels (salicin and salicortin) were similar among all hybrids, with the exception of one sampling date; however, this difference would not likely explain resistance. Neither induced or constitutive polyphenol oxidase (PPO) activity nor induced levels of secondary metabolites could explain resistance. Thus, we conclude hybrids that contain P. maximowiczii parentage have a novel mechanism for resistance.