Response to recurrent disturbance in two co-occurring resprouter heath species: the ecological consequences of withstanding herbivores

Resprouting woody plants are vulnerable to large mammal herbivores in the early stages of regeneration after disturbance (e.g., fire, slashing), because herbivory reduces the storage of below-ground starch reserves and may thus compromise regeneration success. Defence from herbivory may incur a cost to resprouter plants in terms of lengthening the time to recovery of pre-disturbance starch levels. Erica scoparia and E. australis (Ericaceae), two resprouter woody species that co-occur in Mediterranean heath-communities of the Strait of Gibraltar, differ in the way they cope with herbivory: E. scoparia is browsing-tolerant and E. australis is a browsing-avoider. Our experimental field study demonstrated that exposure to a moderate density of ungulate herbivores markedly lowered starch re-storage after resprouting in E. scoparia, but not in E. australis. Nevertheless, time to recover pre-disturbance starch levels was shorter in the tolerant E. scoparia, even under exposure to herbivores. The slower starch recovery rate of E. australis is a likely outcome of its resource-demanding browsing-avoidance mechanism. Differences in starch recovery rates after disturbance between the two Erica species partly explains their ecological segregation at the landscape scale.