Contrasting population makeup of two intertidal gastropod species that differ in dispersal opportunities

This study of population structure of two intertidal monodontine species: Diloma nigerrima and Diloma subrostrata, revealed the level of genetic connectedness among populations. Despite their markedly different geographic ranges (D. nigerrima is a geographically widespread species, inhabiting both Chile and New Zealand, including its subantarctic islands, whereas D. subrostrata is endemic to New Zealand), both species are believed to possess short-lived lecithotrophic larval stages. Polymorphic DNA microsatellite sequences were used to reveal the level of genetic connectedness among populations, thus inferring the two species' relative effective dispersal abilities. For each species F statistics, AMOVA values and the strength of the relationship between geographic and genetic distance were calculated. We observed a higher within-species level of genetic variation (Φ_ST = 0.099 vs. Φ_ST = 0.016) and a higher proportion of variance (11.15% vs. 0%) among populations of D. nigerrima than of D. subrostrata. A larger fraction of significant F_ST values was observed among D. nigerrima population pairs (65%) than among D. subrostrata population pairs (33%). Significant correlation between genetic and geographic distance was observed for D. nigerrima but not for D. subrostrata, but this relationship was not consistent among pairwise D. nigerrima population comparisons and PCA analysis confirms that, for each species, population structure does not follow a consistent pattern of increasing with geographic distance. The lack of population structure among D. subrostrata populations is probably due to its ubiquitous distribution, meaning little opportunity exists for genetic structure. D. nigerrima, by contrast has a patchier distribution, which allows for greater opportunities for genetic differentiation to occur. We argue that, despite the probable short larval stage in this species, the lack of geographical pattern in the genetic structure found in D. nigerrima is best explained by occasional dispersal over relatively short distances around the coast of New Zealand, over longer distances from New Zealand to the subantarctic islands and even across the Pacific Ocean from New Zealand to Chile.