Origin of apparent negative cooperativity of F1-ATPase

In order to get insight into the origin of apparent negative cooperativity observed for F₁-ATPase, we compared ATPase activity and ATPMg binding of mutant subcomplexes of thermophilic F₁-ATPase, α_(W463F)3β_(Y341W)3γ and α_{(K175A/T176A/W463F)3}β_(Y341W)3γ. For α_(W463F)3β_(Y341W)3γ, apparent K_m's of ATPase kinetics (4.0 and 233 μM) did not agree with apparent K_m's deduced from fluorescence quenching of the introduced tryptophan residue (on the order of nM, 0.016 and 13 μM). On the other hand, in case of α_{(K175A/T176A/W463F)3}β_(Y341W)3γ, which lacks noncatalytic nucleotide binding sites, the apparent K_m of ATPase activity (10 μM) roughly agreed with the highest K_m of fluorescence measurements (27 μM). The results indicate that in case of α_(W463F)3β_(Y341W)3γ, the activating effect of ATP binding to noncatalytic sites dominates overall ATPase kinetics and the highest apparent K_m of ATPase activity does not represent the ATP binding to a catalytic site. In case of α_{(K175A/T176A/W463F)3}β_(Y341W)3γ, the K_m of ATPase activity reflects the ATP binding to a catalytic site due to the lack of noncatalytic sites. The Eadie-Hofstee plot of ATPase reaction by α_{(K175A/T176A/W463F)3}β_(Y341W)3γ was rather linear compared with that of α_(W463F)3β_(Y341W)3γ, if not perfectly straight, indicating that the apparent negative cooperativity observed for wild-type F₁-ATPase is due to the ATP binding to catalytic sites and noncatalytic sites. Thus, the frequently observed K_m's of 100-300 μM and 1-30 μM range for wild-type F₁-ATPase correspond to ATP binding to a noncatalytic site and catalytic site, respectively.