Effects of different beta73 amino acids on formation of 14-stranded fibers of Hb S versus double-stranded crystals of Hb C-Harlem

Hb S (alpha(2)beta(2)(6Glu-->Val)) forms polymers, while Hb C-Harlem (alpha(2)beta(2)(6Glu-->Val,73Asp-->Asn)) forms crystals upon oversaturation. Since the only difference between the two is the beta73 amino acid, it follows that this site is a critical determinant in promoting either polymerization or crystallization. Beta73 Asp in Hb S forms a hydrogen bond with beta4 Thr, while beta73 Asn in Hb C-Harlem may inhibit this interaction as well as increase the hydrophobicity at the EF helix beta6 Val acceptor sites. Two new beta73 Hb S variants (beta73 His and Leu) were constructed and analyzed to define other amino acids facilitating formation of Hb S-like polymers versus Hb C-Harlem-like crystals. The two variants that were chosen were expected to either (1) enhance formation of the beta73-beta4 hydrogen bond (beta73 His) or (2) inhibit it and increase the hydrophobicity of the EF helix beta6 Val acceptor sites (beta73 Leu). beta73 His Hb S formed fibers but at a lower concentration than Hb S, while beta73 Leu Hb S formed crystals but at a higher concentration than Hb C-Harlem. The solubility of beta73 His Hb S was (1)/(7) of that of Hb S, while the solubility of beta73 Leu Hb S was similar to that of Hb C-Harlem. The delay time prior to polymer or crystal formation depended on Hb concentration. The delay time for beta73 His Hb S was 10(5)-fold shorter than that for Hb S, while that for beta73 Leu Hb S was 10(5)-fold longer in 1.0 M phosphate buffer. NMR results indicate beta73 amino acid changes induce alteration in the beta-chain heme pocket region, while CD results indicate no change in the helical content of the variants. These results suggest that enhancing the beta73-beta4 hydrogen bond and/or induced changes in the heme pocket by the beta73 Asp to His change facilitate formation of Hb S-like fibers. Our results also suggest that removal of the beta73-beta4 hydrogen bond and enhancing the hydrophobicity of the EF helix beta6 Val acceptor sites by the beta73 Asp to Leu or Asn changes delay nuclei formation and facilitate formation of Hb C-Harlem-like crystals.