Estimating chlorophyll a abundance from the 'phytoplankton colour' recorded by the Continuous Plankton Recorder survey: validation with simultaneous fluorometry

The green colour (measured with reference to standard colourcharts) of sections of the Continuous Plankton Recorder (CPR)filtering silk was compared with estimates of chlorophyll aconcentration derived from a fluorometer mounted on the CPRduring seven tows in the North Sea between February and May1991. After the green colour was assessed, the abundance ofphytoplankton cells on the filtering silks was quantified bymicroscope analysis. Data were collected for 115 10-nautical-milesamples over a total of seven cruises. For these 115 samples,there was only a weak (F_1.113 = 3.8, P = 0.05, r² = 0.03) positiverelationship between the colour of the filtering silk and thechlorophyll a concentration. However, when this comparison wasrestricted to four tows (68 10-nautical-mile samples) wherethe recorded phytoplankton cell abundance on the silks was verylow, there was a highly significant (F_1.66 /,69.1, P < 0.001,r² = 0.51) positive relationship between the silk colour andthe chlorophyll a concentration. By measuring the relative colourintensity of CPR standard colour categories and quantifyingthe individual variation in the assessment of colour, a theoreticalmodel was developed which pedicted that if the silks were colouredin direct proportion to the chlorophyll a concentration in thewater, then the expert r² for the relationship between silkcolour and chlorophyll a concentration would be 0.62. The greencolour recorded by the CPR survey was therefore identified asa quantitative index of chlorophyll a concentration, but onlywhen numbers of phytoplankton cells on the CPR silks are nothigh.