Ontogeny and phylogeny in temnospondyls: a new method of analysis

A new method has been devised to compare the ontogeny and phylogeny of some of the better documented tetrapods from the Stephanian to the Trias. This approach is based on global parsimony analysis of several temnospondyl amphibians, in which some ontogenetic sequences have been highlighted. Forty-one homologous morphoanatomical character states have been separated into larval, juvenile and adult stages of each of six tetrapod species. The taxonomic congruence (TC) approach involves comparing trees based on larval, juvenile and adult character states. These so-called 'ontotrees' are not congruent, either in their topologies or in the distribution of the character states. The total evidence (TE) approach involves a combined analysis of all the character states observed in the various growth stages of the taxa, and is secondarily used in order to test this taxonomic incongruence. In this case, the TE result corroborates the TC analysis: the TE tree is robust and reveals a few homoplasies which cause the taxonomic incongruence. This is interpreted as either the result of heterochronic events in temnospondyl evolution, or as the product of inaccurate identification of larval and metamorphic fossil forms.