The Respiratory Costs of Nitrogen Fixation in Soyabean, Cowpea, and White Clover: II. COMPARISONS OF THE COST OF NITROGEN FIXATION AND THE UTILIZATION OF COMBINED NITROGEN

Plants of soyabean, cowpea, and white clover were grown singlyin pots in Saxcil growth cabinets at 23/18 °C, 30/24 °C,and 20/15 °C, respectively, until seed maturation or for85 d (white clover). Two populations were produced within eachspecies: one population effectively nodulated and wholly dependentfor nitrogen on fixation in the root nodules, and a second populationcompletely lacking nodules but receiving abundant nitrate nitrogen.In each species, the two populations were compared in termsof rate of gross photosynthesis, rate of shoot respiration,and rate of root respiration. Source of nitrogen had littleor no effect on rate of photosynthesis or shoot respiration.In contrast, the rate of respiration of the nodulated rootsof plants fixing their own nitrogen was greater, sometimes two-foldgreater, than that of equivalent plants lacking nodules andutilizing nitrate nitrogen. This superiority in terms of rateof root respiration was generally confined to the period ofintense nitrogen fixation. An analysis of the magnitude of thisrespiratory burden in terms of daily photosynthesis indicatesthat, in all three legumes, plants fixing their own nitrogenrespire 11–13% more of their fixed carbon each day thanequivalent plants lacking nodules and utilizing nitrate nitrogen.