Globorotalia puncticulata: Population divergence, dispersal and extinction related to Pliocene–Quaternary water masses

The isolating effect of water mass partitioning of populations on the morphology, stratigraphic distribution and extinction of planktonic foraminifera is assessed from the Pliocene–Quaternary record of Globorotalia puncticulata. Southern Hemisphere, Mediterranean and North Atlantic data on these aspects of its history are examined and appear consistent with a limited dispersal biogeographic model wherein populations are largely confined by hydrographic barriers.Earliest populations appeared during the latest Miocene in Southern Hemisphere middle latitude water masses. However, morphometric analysis shows that significant differentiation in the axial shape of shells had developed by 4 Ma between Southwest Pacific populations from ODP Site 1123 (temperate water) and ODP Site 1119 (subantarctic water). These sites are in close proximity but separated by the Subtropical Front. At Site 1123 inflation of late-formed chambers and reduction in the number included in the outer whorl created shell profiles that anticipated the globose form of Globorotalia inflata. The latter's gradual evolution from G. puncticulata s.s. took place in this temperate water mass, with the earliest morphotypes with three chambers in the outer whorl present by 4.1 Ma. In contrast, subantarctic populations at Site 1119 retained four chambers but their axial shape was modified. The development of a large, highly arched aperture and increase in the number of chambers in the outer whorl in Mediterranean–North Atlantic Globorotalia puncticulata bononiensis is an example of population differentiation later in the Pliocene.Chronostratigraphy shows that the northward expansion of central temperate water populations commenced with their occupation of Southwest Pacific subtropical water about 4.8 Ma. The rather abrupt entry of substantial populations into Mediterranean and North Atlantic water at 4.5 Ma marked a major biogeographic expansion and established G. puncticulata as a bipolar species. It was widely distributed about 3 Ma, with major populations in several water masses during a period of middle Pliocene warmth.After this acme North Atlantic and Mediterranean G. puncticulata bononiensis populations collapsed as late Pliocene Northern Hemisphere glacials intensified. They were extinguished in MIS 96 (2.4 Ma). Concurrently, G. puncticulata s.s became extinct in the warm subtropical Southwest Pacific. Subantarctic populations persisted but in turn were decimated in severe glacials during the Middle Pleistocene Transition. Most had disappeared by MIS 16 (0.66 Ma). However, at Sites 594 and 1119 there was a small Lazarus-like revival in MIS 11 (0.41 Ma). The highest known occurrence is in MIS 9 (0.33 Ma) at Site 1119. Confinement of the species to subantarctic water in the Pleistocene may have raised its vulnerability to extinction.While stable isotope data indicate that the lineage's evolution is related to depth habitat selection about the thermocline, its biogeography suggests that hydrographic barriers significantly isolated populations and probably facilitated speciation. Eddies such as the North Brazil Current rings provide conduits for inter-water mass transfer of populations but the history of G. puncticulata suggests that such mechanisms seldom operated successfully.The morphology of the lectotype of G. puncticulata s.s., from beach sand at Rimini, Italy, is consistent with a lower Pliocene source. Reports of living occurrences are poorly documented and the species is considered to be extinct.