Comparison of TCE Transformation Abilities of Methane- and Propane-Utilizing Microorganisms

Subsurface microorganisms from McClellan Air Force Base (AFB) were grown in batch aquifer microcosms on methane, propane, and butane to evaluate the potential for aerobic trichloroethylene (TCE) cometabolism. Microorganisms stimulated on all three substrates indicated the existence of a subsurface microbial community capable of utilizing alkanes as growth substrates. Initial growth substrate utilization lag periods of 2 weeks for methane and 3 weeks for propane and butane were observed. Methane- and propane-utilizers were active toward TCE cometabolism, whereas butane-utilizers showed no ability to transform TCE. Gradually increasing TCE concentrations were effectively transformed with uniform additions of methane and propane for up to 1 year. TCE was transformed most rapidly during active methane utilization, and continued at a slower rate for approximately 1 week after methane was consumed. Propane microcosms maintained first-order TCE transformation for up to 4 weeks after propane was consumed. The microbial communities remained active toward primary substrate utilization as the TCE concentration was gradually increased. Both methane- and propane-utilizers showed positive correlations between TCE transformation rates and primary substrate utilization rates. Observed maximum TCE transformation yields were 0.068 g TCE/g methane and 0.048 g TCE/g propane. The methane-utilizers also transformed chloroform (CF) but not 1,1,1-trichloroethane (1,1,1-TCA). Propane-utilizers transformed both CF and 1,1,1-TCA, indicating they were better suited for cometabolizing chlorinated aliphatic hydrocarbon mixtures in the McClellan AFB subsurface.