Restoration of fen ecosystems in the Vecht River plain: cost-benefit analysis of hydrological alternatives

In the Vecht river plain, the vegetation diversity has been diminished during recent decades, due to hydrological changes and resulting eutrophication. Different options are discussed for hydrological management aimed at abating the eutrophication and at stimulating the characteristic mesotraphent succession phases of the fen vegetation. The ecological impact of the management plans are estimated with the hydro-ecological model ICHORS; this model takes into account the relations between the non-biotic environment and the presence of hydrophytes and phreatophytes. The impact of the hydrological options is assessed, after rearrangement of the predicted values of the species to values of the required fen vegetation. These results are incorporated in the management options with the water balances of the polders. Information on the costs of the options is used as a basis for a cost-benefit analysis. Technical hydrological solutions such as purification of the supplied water might contribute to the eutrophication abatement, but they are on their own unlikely to restore the ecosystems. Contrastingly, options involving the restoration of the original hydrology would probably lead to the characteristic mesotraphent fen vegetation once more, and the financial implications of this are likely to be the more favourable in the long-term.