Size analyses of the coccolith species Biscutum constans and Watznaueria barnesiae from the Late Albian “Niveau Breistroffer” (SE France): taxonomic and palaeoecological implications

The size variability of the coccolith species Biscutum constans and Watznaueria barnesiae has been studied in 50 samples of the Late Albian “Niveau Breistroffer” black shales (Col de Palluel section, SE France). For each species, length and width of the total coccolith and the central unit have been measured in 60 specimens per sample. In addition, ellipticity and central unit length/total coccolith length ratio have been calculated. This study aims to improve our understanding of the taxonomic concepts of B. constans and W. barnesiae, and to test whether the size changes correspond to palaeoceanographic changes interpreted from other proxies. Two morphotypes (varieties) were differentiated for each of the two taxa studied. B. constans includes morphotypes with a narrow (B. constans var. constans) and a wide central unit (B. constans var. ellipticum). Between these two morphotypes no significant size differentiation has been observed. They seem to represent end members of a size continuum, relating to both the total coccolith- and central unit size distribution. The two morphotypes of W. barnesiae differ only in the absence (W. barnesiae var. barnesiae) and the presence of a narrow central opening (W. barnesiae var. fossacincta). No significant size differences have been observed between these two morphotypes, and both show similar distributions of the measured characteristics. We recommend that the studied morphotypes of both B. constans and W. barnesiae should not be assigned to different morphospecies. Throughout the studied black shale succession the measured parameters show mostly statistically insignificant, short-term fluctuations, but significant long-term trends have been observed for B. constans. These show a trend to smaller forms with a narrower central unit in the upper part of the succession. This change coincides with a cooling trend, as indicated by a nannofossil based temperature index. Therefore the two morphotypes of B. constans are interpreted to represent ecophenotypic varieties rather than two different morphospecies. No clear relationship has been recognized between the size of W. barnesiae and the palaeoenvironmental conditions.