Milk yield and milk composition responses to change in predicted net energy and metabolizable protein: a meta-analysis

Using a meta-analysis of literature data, this study aimed to quantify the dry matter (DM) intake response to changes in diet composition, and milk responses (yield, milk component yields and milk composition) to changes in dietary net energy for lactation (NE_L) and metabolizable protein (MP) in dairy cows. From all studies included in the database, 282 experiments (825 treatments) with experimentally induced changes in either NE_L or MP content were kept for this analysis. These treatments covered a wide range of diet characteristics and therefore a large part of the plausible NE_L and MP contents and supplies that can be expected in practical situations. The average MP and NE_L contents were, respectively (mean±SD), 97±12 g/kg DM and 6.71±0.42 MJ/kg DM. On a daily supply basis, there were high between-experiment correlations for MP and NE_L above maintenance. Therefore, supplies of MP and NE_L above maintenance were, respectively, centred on MP supply for which MP efficiency into milk protein is 0.67, and NE_L above maintenance supply for which the ratio of NE_L milk/NE_L above maintenance is 1.00 (centred variables were called MP₆₇ and NE_L100). The majority of the selected studies used groups of multiparous Holstein-Friesian cows in mid lactation, milked twice a day. Using a mixed model, between- and within-experiment variation was split to estimate DM intake and milk responses. The use of NE_L100 and MP₆₇ supplies substantially improved the accuracy of the prediction of milk yield and milk component yields responses with, on average, a 27% lower root mean square error (RMSE) relative to using dietary NE_L and MP contents as predictors. For milk composition (g/kg), the average RMSE was only 3% lower on a supply basis compared with a concentration basis. Effects of NE_L and MP supplies on milk yield and milk component yields responses were additive. Increasing NE_L supply increases energy partitioning towards body reserve, whereas increasing MP supply increases the partition of energy towards milk. On a nitrogen basis, the marginal efficiency decreases with increasing MP supply from 0.34 at MP₆₇=−400 g/day to 0.07 at MP₆₇=300 g/day. This difference in MP₆₇ supply, assuming reference energy level of NE_L100=0, equates to a global nitrogen efficiency decrease from 0.82 to 0.58. The equations accurately describe DM intake response to change in dietary contents and milk responses to change in dietary supply and content of NE_L and MP across a wide range of dietary compositions.