Effects of temporary desiccation on the mobility of phosphorus and metals in sulphur-rich fens: differential responses of sediments and consequences for water table management

In the Netherlands, permanent damming of sulphate (SO₄ ^2–)-rich surface water, in order to rewet desiccated wetlands, has resulted in stagnation and eutrophication of surface water. Permanent damming of surface water prevents periodic drought during summer and leads to suppressed iron (Fe)-rich groundwater input and to stimulated SO₄ ^2– reduction, all likely stimulating depletion of reducible Fe in the sediment. A laboratory experiment was conducted to assess the importance of temporary desiccation, its differential effects on various sediment types and the consequences for water table management. Permanent high SO₄ ^2–-rich surface water tables above sediments that are indirectly affected by shallow groundwater flows, resulted in severe eutrophication. The effect of temporary desiccation on phosphorus (P) mobilization and immobilization strongly depended on the sediment Fe and P pools in combination with the buffering capacity of the sediment. Desiccation of sediment that is indirectly affected by shallow groundwater flows, led to a long-lasting reduction in phosphate (o-PO₄ ^3–) release from the sediment because a reduced Fe pool is present, resulting in the release of Fe upon oxidation. Formerly dry sediments that have not been influenced by groundwater for a long time do not possess such a reduced Fe pool and desiccation did not reduce P-release from these sediments resulting in considerable eutrophication of the water layer immediately after rewetting. In sediment of seepage zones that are directly and permanently influenced by deeper groundwater, reduced Fe and calcium levels are so high that o-PO₄ ^3– was effectively immobilized under oxidized as well as reduced conditions. The results indicate that restoration of desiccated wetlands can not be achieved by simply retaining water by means of constructed dams. If water retention is artificially increased, temporary drops in water level during the summer are necessary to recharge the reducible P-binding Fe pool in large zones of the wetlands in order to prevent eutrophication.