Warning coloration in sawflyAthalia rosae larva and concealing coloration in butterflyPieris rapae larva feeding on similar plants evolved through individual selection

Green larvae of the butterfly Pieris rapae and black larvae of the sawfly Athalia rosae feed on green leaves of the same cruciferous plants. To demonstrate that P. rapae has concealing coloration and that A. rosae has warning coloration, the larvae of the two species were supplied to naive chicks Gallus gallus on white, green or black backgrounds. P. rapae larvae were palatable and their green body color acted as a concealing coloration. On the other hand, A. rosae larvae were unpalatable and their black body color acted as a warning coloration. There is a general consensus that warning coloration is an altruistic character which needs victims, and thus can evolve through kin selection or green beard selection. However, black A. rosae larvae were seldom injured by chicks' attack, in particular, on the green background. Therefore, the warning coloration of A. rosae larvae can be a selfish character and hence can evolve through individual selection as well as concealing coloration of P. rapae.