Reactive Nitrogen Species-Dependent Effects on Soybean Chloroplasts

Nitric oxide (NO) generation by soybean (Glycine max, var ADM 4800) chloroplasts was studied by electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) spin-trapping technique.¹ Both nitrite and L-arginine (arg) are the required substrates for enzymatic activities considered as possible sources of NO in plants. Soybean chloroplasts showed a NO production of 3.2 ± 0.2 nmol min⁻¹ mg⁻¹ protein in the presence of 1 mM NaNO₂. Chloroplasts incubated with 1 mM arg showed a NO production of 0.76 ± 0.04 nmol min⁻¹ mg⁻¹ protein. This production was inhibited when chloroplasts were incubated in presence of NOS-inhibitors L-NAME and L-NNA. In vitro exposure of chloroplasts to a NO-donor (GSNO) decreased both ascorbyl radical content and the activity of ascorbate peroxidase, without modification of the total ascorbate content. Exposure of the isolated chloroplasts to a NO-donor decreased lipid radical content in membranes, however, incubation in the presence of 25 µM peroxynitrite (ONOO⁻) led to an increase in lipid-derived radicals (34%). The effect of ONOO⁻ on protein oxidation was determined by western blotting, showing an increase in carbonyl content either in stroma or thylakoid proteins as compared to control. Taken as a whole, NO seems to be an endogenous metabolite in soybean chloroplasts and reactive nitrogen species could exert either antioxidant or prooxidant effects on chloroplasts, since both a decreased lipid radical content in membranes and a decrease in the activity of ascorbate peroxidase were observed after exposure to a NO donor.Key Words: ascorbate, ascorbate peroxidase, chloroplasts, nitric oxide, peroxynitriteThe origin of nitric oxide (NO) in plants under aerobic conditions is currently under study. Although plants with low level of arginine shows arg-stimulated NO accumulation,² the mechanism for arginine-dependent NO synthesis in plants is still unknown, because the detection of an animal-type NOS remains elusive to date.^3,4 Even though assimilatory nitrate reductase is an enzymatic source of NO, its role in vivo would be limited by both its cytosolic localization which difficult the availability for nitrite, and the relative high K_m for nitrite (100 µM).⁵Chloroplasts have been previously marked as NO sources based in nonquantitative studies employing fluorescence microscopy^6,7 and immunogold electron microscopy.⁸ In our work we employed an specific technique (EPR, electron paramagnetic resonance with spin trap⁹) to detect NO as an endogenous metabolite and to quantify its generation in the presence of different substrates. In order to gain insight on the mechanism leading to NO production both nitrite-dependent and arg-dependent pathways were evaluated. In the presence of 1 mM arg and 0.1 mM NADPH the rate of NO generation was 0.76 ± 0.04 nmol min⁻¹ mg⁻¹ prot (arg-dependent synthesis). The synthesis of NO resulted completely blocked in the presence of arg analogs (L-NAME and L-NNA). It is important to point out that the content of arg in the chloroplasts stroma is high as compared to the content of other amino acids (56.7 ± 0.8 nmol mg⁻¹ prot), suggesting that this pathway could be operative under physiological conditions.Soybean chloroplasts showed a NO production of 3.2 ± 0.2 nmol min⁻¹ mg⁻¹ prot in the presence of 1 mM NaNO₂. Furthermore, NO generation was detected in the presence of nitrite concentrations as low as 25 mM. Since nitrite-dependent NO generation resulted inhibited by 50% by the addition of DCMU, and no NO generation was measured in the stroma fraction, thylakoidal electron transport seems to be a key feature in NO synthesis.According to this scenario and assuming that the two independent pathways for NO generation in chloroplasts are operative, the total rate of production of NO could be understood as the generation by the activity of an arg-dependent enzyme and by a NO₂⁻ dependent pathway, as indicated by eq. 1.dNO]dt=(dNO]dt)NOS like+(dNO]dt)NO2−(1)Regarding the NO disappearance, from a kinetic point of view, the rate of the reaction of NO with O₂⁻ to generate peroxynitrite seems to be the main pathway, since the reaction is diffusionally controlled. Thus, the rate of disappearance of NO could be estimated from the rate of generation of ONOO⁻ (eq. 2); however, other reactions should be considered under nonphysiological conditions.−dNO]dt=d⌊ONOO−⌋dt=kNO]O2−](2)NO generation rate should be equal to NO consumption rate in order to keep a physiological NO steady state concentration (eq. 3)dNO]dt=−dNO]dt(3)Thus, replacing NO generation and disappearance rates by those rates indicated in equations 1 and 2, (dNO]dt)NOS like+(dNO]dt)NO2−=kNO]O2−](4) The data obtained under unrestricted availability of substrates, indicate a generation rate of NO by the activity of a NOS-like enzyme of 13 × 10⁻⁹ M s⁻¹. Chloroplastic NO generation rate in the presence of 100 µM NO₂⁻ was 14 × 10⁻⁹ M s⁻¹. Thus, according to equation 1, the rate of generation of NO is approximately 3 × 10⁻⁸ M s⁻¹. Assuming a steady state concentration for O₂⁻ of 1 nM in chloroplasts¹⁰ and a rate constant (k) of 6.9 × 10⁹ M⁻¹ s⁻¹ for the reaction between O₂⁻ and NO,¹¹ a steady state concentration of 4 nM for NO in the chloroplast could be estimated. Since under in vivo conditions chloroplasts may content the required substrates for the NO synthesis, the assays presented here strongly suggest that a feasible NO production could take place inside the chloroplasts. However, nonsupplemented chloroplasts did not show any NO-dependent EPR signal. This observation agrees with the fact that NO steady state concentration under physiological conditions as was calculated here (4 nM) is below the EPR detection limit (500 nM).¹²Further studies should be performed to characterize NO oxidative effects on chloroplasts. Scavenging of O₂⁻ and H₂O₂ is essential for chloroplasts to maintain their ability to fix CO₂ since several enzymes in the CO₂-reduction cycle are sensitive to active oxygen species.¹³ These organelles lacking catalase, contain a significant peroxidase activity.¹⁴ H₂O₂-reduction catalized by ascorbate peroxidase (AP) lead to ascorbate oxidation and produces ascorbyl radical (A^.).¹⁵ In isolated chloroplast the content of A^.. was evaluated in DMSO based extract by EPR¹⁶. Quantification of EPR signals indicated that A^. content in control chloroplasts (123 ± 5 pmol mg⁻¹ prot) decreased after exposure to NO (Fig. 1). The total content of ascorbate, assessed by an HPLC technique¹⁷ in chloroplasts isolated from soybean leaves exposed to NO was not significantly different from the measured content in chloroplasts not exposed to the NO donor (Fig. 1). The activity of AP was significantly decreased by 48, 53 and 54% after exposure of the chloroplasts to NO-donor. Previous data suggested that AP could be inactivated by NO via oxidation of functional thiols.¹⁸ Besides, the reversible inhibition of AP could be due to the formation of Fe-nitrosyl complexes between NO and the Fe atom of the heme group, as it was previously described for NO-mediated activation of guanylate cyclase and the inhibition of cytochrome P₄₅₀ and catalase in mammals.¹⁹ The data presented here showed that in isolated chloroplasts exposed to a NO donor, there could be either a limited damage associated to the decrease in the content of A^.. or an increased cellular deterioration by the decrease in the activity of the enzyme responsible for the scavenging of H₂O₂.Open in a separate windowFigure 1Ascorbate metabolism in soybean chloroplasts after NO exposure. A^.. content (▪), ascorbate content (▪), and AP activity (*) as a function of the exposure of isolated chloroplasts to GSNO in the presence of 50 µM DTT. * = significantly different at p ≥ 0.05 from the value obtained in the absence of GSNO + 50 µM DTT.Thus, in situ generation of NO could play a protective role in preventing the oxidation of chloroplastic lipids; however, the reaction of NO with O₂⁻ leading to ONOO⁻ production may result in a potential source of damage or as it is shown here by the significant decrease of the AP activity that consumes H₂O₂. NO is a suitable candidate to modulate cellular H₂O₂ level through the chloroplast function, as an initial step to regulate complex metabolic pathways directed to activate physiological responses, defense pathways or deleterious effects in the cytosol. Furthermore, an integrated study on the effect of nitrogen reactive species is required under stress conditions to characterize the metabolic pathways involved in the resulting cellular damage.