Genetically modified CD34+ cells do not contribute to the mesenchymal compartment after autologous transplantation in the baboon

BACKGROUND: There is ongoing controversy about the transdifferentiation of hematopoietic stem cells (HSC) into different tissues such as mesenchymal cells. This transdifferentiation or 'plasticity' would be an appealing concept for many therapeutic strategies. While studies in the murine model show encouraging results, reports from clinical allogeneic stem cell transplantations do not support the concept of HSC plasticity. Our aim was to determine whether transplantation of transduced autologous marrow CD34+ cells leads to long-term engraftment of gene-marked cells with mesenchymal characteristics in the baboon. METHODS: We analyzed marrow of two baboons that had received green fluorescence protein (GFP)-marked CD34+ autologous marrow cells after myeloablative conditioning. Marrow was obtained 1 and 2.5 years after transplantation and adherent CD11a- (pan-leukocyte Ab) cells were cultured for 3 weeks. Cultures were then analyzed by flow cytometry and fluorescence microscopy for the presence of GFP+ cells. For further analysis fresh and cultured cells were also labeled with multiple Ab and functional analysis was performed. RESULTS: Both animals showed persistent and stable GFP marking by flow cytometry in peripheral blood leukocytes as well as in CD34+ marrow cells at 1 and 2.5 years after transplantation. There was no evidence of GFP+ mesenchymal cells by either flow cytometry or fluorescence microscopy, while functional and phenotypical analysis identified mesenchymal stem cells in these cultures. DISCUSSION: We conclude that genetically modified CD34+ cells do not contribute to the adherent marrow-derived mesenchymal cell population after autologous transplantation.