Substitution of choline by related compounds in the diet of Argyrotaenia velutinana and Heliothis virescens

Argyrotaenia velutinana, the red-banded leaf roller, and Heliothis virescens, the tobacco budworm, both require choline for growth and development when reared on semisynthetic diets. The optimum level for A. velutinana is $\text{50 mg}\text{100 g}$ of diet whereas that for H. virescens exceeds $\text{100 mg}\text{100 g}$ of diet.No choline analog tested can adequately replace choline in the diet. One compound, dimethylethylcholine, will permit some adut emergence but development is slower and mortality is greater than on the corresponding diet containing choline. This is in sharp contrast to a number of Diptera in which mary choline analogs can not only replace choline in the diet but are also incorporated into phospholipids analogous to phosphatidylcholine.In A. velutinana, dimethylisopropylcholine and β-methylcholine, although inadequate as choline replacements, can spare the dietary choline requirement, Isopropylethanolamine is a growth inhibitor for A. velutinana but not for H. virescens.