Dual recognition of S 1 and S 4 pistils by S 4 sm pollen in self-incompatibility of Japanese pear (Pyrus pyrifolia Nakai)

Most cultivars of Japanese pear (Pyrus pyrifolia Nakai) exhibit gametophytic self-incompatibility controlled by a single S-locus with multiple S-haplotypes. A self-compatible (SC) cultivar, ??Osanijisseiki?? (S ₂ S ₄ ^sm ), arising by a bud mutation of ??Nijisseiki?? (S ₂ S ₄ ), has a stylar-part mutant S ₄ ^sm -haplotype, which lacks the pistil S ₄ gene, which is the S ₄ -RNase gene. To efficiently breed SC cultivars, we selected ??Nashi Chuukanbohon Nou 1 Gou?? (??NCN1??) harboring homozygous S ₄ ^sm from a self-progeny of Osanijisseiki and crossed it with ??Okusankichi?? (S ₅ S ₇ ), ??Hakkou?? (S ₄ S ₅ ), or ??Ri-14?? (S ₁ S ₂ ). Fruit set (%) was compared after self-pollination of the trees in the three progenies. All trees derived from the three progenies were predicted to be SC, except for the S ₄ S ₄ ^sm trees in the progeny of NCN1 × Hakkou. However, S ₁ S ₄ ^sm trees in the progeny of NCN1 × Ri-14 proved to be self-incompatible (SI). The pollen from Osanijisseiki was incompatible with ??Doitsu?? (S ₁ S ₂ ), but that from Nijisseiki was compatible, suggesting a possibility that the S ₄ ^sm pollen was rejected by S ₁ -harboring pistils. This possibility was clarified by crossing the pollen from NCN1 (S ₄ ^sm S ₄ ^sm ) to Doitsu, ??Imamuraaki?? (S ₁ S ₆ ), or ??Hougetsu?? (S ₁ S ₇ ), all of which proved incompatible. On the other hand, S ₄ ^sm pollen was accepted by pistils harboring the S ₂ , S ₃ , S ₅ , S ₆ , S ₇ , S ₉ , and S _k haplotypes. The dual recognition of S ₁ and S ₄ pistils by S ₄ ^sm pollen can be attributed to a mutation of the pollen S ₄ gene(s).