Phylogeography of lateral plate dimorphism in the freshwater type of ninespine sticklebacks, genus Pungitius

The freshwater type of ninespine sticklebacks, genus Pungitius, is widely distributed in northern Japan and reproductively isolated from other genetically divergent types endemic to small regions in Japan. This type expresses dimorphism in its lateral plate morphology: complete and partial row morphs. The two morphs show a parapatric distribution in Japan. To clarify the process involving the distribution of these two morphs, we examined their phylogeography based on restriction fragment length polymorphism of an entire mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA). The survey was carried out with seven restriction enzymes on the populations of the freshwater type collected from 41 localities across the distribution range in Japan, and 6 further Pungitius populations from the Okhotsk Sea coast of Russia were appended. An unweighted pair-group method with arithmetic averages (UPGMA) tree among 54 mtDNA haplotypes resolved eight clustering groups that differed in sequence divergence by approximately 1.3%–2.1%. Two of the eight groups were found only in Russia. mtDNA phylogenies constructed by neighbor-joining and Wagner parsimony methods suggested that the haplotypes of each plate morph were polyphyletic. The geographic distribution pattern of these groups suggests that they should be classified into two broad categories, one with extensive distribution and the other with localized distribution of the constituent haplotypes within a group. The former groups were found mainly in the populations with the completely plated morph and the latter groups with the partially plated morph. It is supposed that twice dispersals of dimorphic or complete plated ancestors and genetic differentiation during the interglacial played an important role in the formation of the present distribution of the two morphs in Japan. Received: March 28, 2000 / Revised: November 3, 2000 / Accepted: January 16, 2001