Comparison of three nonradioactive and a radioactive DNA probe for the detection of target DNA by DNA hybridization

The specificity and sensitivity of three methods for the preparation and detection of nonradioactive probe DNA (biotin-nick translation, biotin-photolabel, and antigen-chemical linkage) were evaluated and compared with a nick-translated³²P-labeled DNA probe in DNA hybridization studies. The DNA probes were prepared from a restriction fragment (HindIII-3) from bacteriophage P1 DNA, and target DNA consisted of purified phage P1 DNA or P1 prophage DNA in lysogens ofEscherichia coli. A probe concentration of 50 ng/ml resulted in clear detection with the three nonradioactiveHindIII-3 DNA probes, whereas the specificity of the³²P-HindIII-3 DNA probe was satisfactory at a concentration of 25 ng/ml. However, the detection of false positives was greater with the³²P-labeled probe. The sensitivity of the radiolabeled DNA probe was marginally greater than that of the nonradioactive probes in dot blot hybridizations with purified phage P1 DNA. However, when the preparation time, ease of use, safety, duration of storage, and expense were compared for the four methods of labeling, the nonradiolabeled probes were generally superior to the radiolabeled probe.