The regulation of human blastoid research: A bioethical discussion of the limits of regulation

The creation of human blastoids holds great potential for research on early human development but also raises considerations about the ethics of such research and its regulation. Subject Categories: Development, Economics, Law & Politics

Developmental research has made considerable progress modeling either part of or the entire embryonic development of both humans and non‐human animals. A major step forward was the ability to grow blastocyst‐like structures from pluripotent stem cells: these structures, known as “blastoids,” mimic early embryonic development up to and potentially beyond the blastocyst stage 5–6 days after the first cell division. Blastoids have attracted considerable attention as an effective research tool to understand early human development and to elucidate the causes of infertility, teratogenesis, and other developmental abnormalities.

… many scientists see the use of human blastoids as an exciting scientific opportunity, as it may help to reduce the need for human embryos in research.

Until now, research with blastoids has mainly studied early development in mice, but, as of 2021, research results are also being reported from human blastoids (see “Further Reading”). Indeed, many scientists see the use of human blastoids as an exciting scientific opportunity, as it may help to reduce the need for human embryos in research (Ravindran, ²⁰²¹). However, as with any research that uses human embryos or human stem cells derived from embryos, human blastoid research raises ethical questions and is subject to regulation and approval. The latest ISSCR guidelines state that “[f]orms of research with embryos … and stem cell‐based embryo models … are permissible only after review and approval through a specialized scientific and ethics review process” (ISSCR, ²⁰²¹). Thus, although blastoids are models of embryonic development, they are currently considered to require the same or similar ethical considerations as blastocysts or cells derived from human embryos. In fact, Australia made a decision to regulate blastoid research in the same manner as research on human embryos (Australia NHMRC, ²⁰²¹).