Joint field experiments for comparisons of measuring methods of photosynthetic production

During the 1st GAP Workshop at Konstanz in April 1982 comparativemeasurements of phytoplankton primary production by severaltechniques were conducted simultaneously at an offshore stationin Lake Konstanz and an experimental algal pond. Suspended glassbottle exposure techniques using ¹⁴C and ¹³C uptake gave P_z(mg C m^–3 h^–1) values which varied considerablynear-surface, but estimates of areal rates for the euphoticzone P_cu(mg C m^–3 h^–1) which were reasonably close.In the lake, P_z, from a vertical tube exposure (with ¹⁴C uptake)was greater than rates derived for integrated bottle samples.The oxygen bottle method permitted a good estimate of compensationdepth, corresponding to in situ growth studies. There were difficultiesin direct comparison between O₂ and carbon methods. Correlationbetween them for P_z was good in the lake but poor in the pond,both for suspended bottle and vertical tube methods. This seriesdemonstrates that despite reasonable overall estimates, comparativelyminor methodological differences in experimental technique cancause large variation. ⁺ Coordinator of the group for comparative measurements of photosyntheticproduction at the GAP Workshop, Konstanz, April 1982. ^*This paper is the result of a study made at the Group for AquaticPrimary Productivity (GAP) First International Workshop heldat the Limnological Institute, University of Konstanz, in April1982.