Mutualism between Thisbe irenea butterflies and ants, and the role of ant ecology in the evolution of larval-ant associations

A facultative mutualism between the riodinid butterfly Thisbe irenea and the ponerine ant Ectatomma ruidum is described from Panama. Ants protect larvae against attacks of predatory wasps, but not against tachinid parasitoids. Several potential sources of ecological variation affecting the larval survival of Thisbe irenea are noted. A preliminary means of testing the ability of larvae to appease ants is described that may be applied to all butterfly-ant systems. Observations and literature records indicate that ant taxa which tend butterfly larvae are the same taxa that tend extrafloral nectaries and Homoptera. A general hypothesis for the evolution of myrmecophily among butterflies suggests that ant taxa which utilize secretions in their diet are major selective agents for the evolution of the larval ant-organs, and hence, ant-larval mutualisms. This idea is extended to suggest how appeasement of predaceous ant taxa through the use of larval ant-organs can influence an ant-larval relationship, eventually leading to mutualism.