| Abstract: | Endophilin B1/BAX-interacting factor 1 (Bif-1) is a protein that cooperates with dynamin-like protein 1 (DLP1/Drp1) to maintain normal mitochondrial outer membrane (MOM) dynamics in healthy cells and also contributes to BAX-driven MOM permeabilization (MOMP), the irreversible commitment point to cell death for the majority of apoptotic stimuli. However, despite its importance, exactly how Bif-1 fulfils its proapoptotic role is unknown. Here, we demonstrate that the stimulatory effect of Bif-1 on BAX-driven MOMP and on BAX conformational activation observed in intact cells during apoptosis can be recapitulated in a simplified system consisting of purified proteins and MOM-like liposomes. In this reconstituted model system the N-BAR domain of Bif-1 reproduced the stimulatory effect of Bif-1 on functional BAX activation. This process was dependent on physical interaction between Bif-1 N-BAR and BAX as well as on the presence of the mitochondrion-specific lipid cardiolipin. Despite that Bif-1 N-BAR produced large scale morphological rearrangements in MOM-like liposomes, this phenomenon could be separated from functional BAX activation. Furthermore, DLP1 also caused global morphological changes in MOM-like liposomes, but DLP1 did not stimulate BAX-permeabilizing function in the absence or presence of Bif-1. Taken together, our findings not only provide direct evidence for a functional interplay between Bif-1, BAX, and cardiolipin during MOMP but also add significantly to the growing body of evidence indicating that components of the mitochondrial morphogenesis machinery possess proapoptotic functions that are independent from their recognized roles in normal mitochondrial dynamics.MOMP3 is a key event in the intrinsic pathway of mammalian apoptosis, resulting in the release of several apoptogenic proteins from the mitochondrial intermembrane space into the cytosol (1). Released intraorganellar components, including cytochrome c, Smac/DIABLO, and AIF, then act as mediators for activating executioner caspase proteases or for other downstream events in the intracellular apoptosis cascade. MOMP is tightly regulated by BCL-2 family members, whose core components are proapoptotic BAX-type proteins that directly effect MOMP and antiapoptotic BCL-2-type proteins which inhibit MOMP (2, 3). In a currently popular model, a third subgroup of BCL-2 family proteins, the BH3-only proteins, trigger a set of conformational changes in BAX and/or its close homologue BAK that activates their permeabilizing function, thereby causing MOMP.Multiple proteins implicated in mitochondrial morphogenesis during normal growth conditions can cross-talk with BCL-2 family members to affect the mitochondrial pathway of apoptosis (4). For example, the large dynamin-like GTPase DLP1/Drp1 and hFis1, two essential components of the mitochondrial fission machinery, have been shown to modulate pro-apoptotic BAX function and mitochondrial cytochrome c release by acting at the level of the MOM (5–7). However, although excessive mitochondrial fragmentation is characteristic in mammalian apoptosis, controversy persists as to whether this phenomenon is merely coincident with or causatively linked to MOMP induction (4 – 8). In addition, a considerable body of evidence has amassed indicating that DLP1/Drp1 and hFis1 are multifunctional proteins that do not use the same mechanisms to reshape mitochondria in healthy conditions and to promote release of mitochondrial intermembrane space proteins during apoptosis (7–10).Endophilin B1/BAX-interacting factor 1 (Bif-1) is another protein linking mitochondrial morphological changes and BCL-2-regulated programmed cell death (4). On the one hand, Bif-1 is known to participate downstream of DLP1/Drp1, modulating normal MOM morphological dynamics in healthy cells (11). On the other hand, in response to specific apoptotic signals, a significant portion of Bif-1 binds BAX at the MOM in close temporal correlation with BAX conformational change and cytochrome c release (12). In addition, increasing the levels of Bif-1 has been shown to accelerate BAX conformational change, caspase activation, and apoptotic cell death, whereas loss of Bif-1 delays all these processes (12, 13). Together, these previous findings point to an important contributing role of Bif-1 in BAX-driven MOMP during apoptosis, but the underlying molecular mechanism remains unknown.As other members of the endophilin family, Bif-1 contains an N-BAR (Bin-amphiphysin-Rvs) domain that has been shown to confer ability to these proteins for transforming flat lipid bilayers into high curvature buds, tubules, and vesicles in vitro (14–17). Crystallographic studies of the N-BAR domain of endophilin A1, a close homologue of Bif-1, revealed a crescent-shape homodimer with a positively charged concave surface which is believed to act like a molecular scaffold that impresses its own curvature on binding to negatively charged membranes (16, 18). Another distinguishing feature of endophilin N-BAR domains is the presence of two distinct amphipathic segments referred to as “Helix 0” (H0) and “Helix 1 insert” (H1I) that penetrate only partway into the external leaflet and are thought to create a wedge effect that also increases membrane curvature. This dual curvature-generating mechanism has been linked to the shared capacity of endophilins to operate in membrane tubulovesicular dynamics during normal cell growth together with dynamin/dynamin-like proteins (16–18). However, exactly how the molecular-scale perturbation of membrane curvature induced by N-BAR domains translates into large scale membrane remodeling processes (e.g. tubulation and vesiculation) is not well understood (19–25). In addition, it is unclear whether the ability of Bif-1 to produce global changes in membrane morphology is functionally connected to its apoptotic mode of action.The complexity of the network of intermolecular interactions that controls the BCL-2-regulated MOMP pathway constitutes a major hurdle for gaining a molecular-level understanding of Bif-1 pro-death function in intact cells. Another complicating factor is that Bif-1 can interact with binding partners other than BAX at intracellular membranes distinct from the MOM depending on environmental conditions (14, 26–29). In previous studies this and other laboratories have shown that the BCL-2-regulated MOMP pathway can be reconstituted in a simplified system consisting of purified recombinant proteins and chemically defined MOM-like large unilamellar vesicles (LUV) in a manner that faithfully reflects the basic physiological functions of BCL-2 family proteins at the MOM (30–33). Here, we have used this minimal cell-free system to advance our understanding of the pro-death role of Bif-1. We provide strong evidence for a direct implication of Bif-1 in functional BAX activation at the membrane level and novel insights concerning the mechanism through which Bif-1 achieves this effect. |
