A critical assessment of the use of lipophilic cations as membrane potential probes

A critical review has been made of the literature on the use of lipophilic cations, such as triphenylmethyl phosphonium (TPMP⁺) as membrane potential probes in prokaryotes, uekaryote organelles in vitro, and eukaryote cells. An ideal lipophilic cation should be capable of penetrating through a biological membrane and obey the Nernst equation between a membrane bound phase and its environment. Many different forms of the Nernst equation are presented, useful in the calculation equilibrium potentials of lipophilic cations across membranes. Lipophilic cations appear to behave as valid membrane potential probes in prokaryotes and eukaryote organelles in vitro and even in vivo although some technical difficulties may be involved. On the other hand in valid forms of the Nernst equation have often been used to calculate the equilibrium potential of lipophilic cations across the plasma membranes of eukaryotic cells. In particular, the problem of intracellular compartmentation of lipophilic cations has often not been appreciated. Lipophilic cations do not appear to behave as reliable plasma membrane potential probes in eukaryotic cells. Some other avenues are discussed which might be useful in the determination of the plasma membrane potentials of small eukaryotic cells, e.g. the use of lipophilic anions as membrane potential probes.