Asymmetrical competition between Neotropical dung beetles and its consequences for assemblage structure

Abstract.  1. This study combines the results of laboratory experiments using representative assemblage components and pitfall trapping over a large geographical area to examine the hypothesis that ongoing interspecific competition structures Neotropical dung beetle assemblages.
2. From Guatemala to Panama assemblages of large to medium-sized, fast-tunnelling dung beetles include a single large, nocturnal dichotomiine species, Dichotomius annae (Kohlmann & Solís, 1997). In competition experiments, this species out-competed the medium-sized coprine species, Copris lugubris Boheman and Phanaeus demon Laporte-Castelnau, for dung and nesting space, in spite of earlier colonisation by the diurnal species, P. demon .
3. Differences in the abundance of D. annae at Central American sites did not affect total fast-tunnelling dung beetle assemblage richness over the rainy season. However, D. annae rank order was directly related to the probability of interspecific encounters (Hurlbert's Δ ₁) among species. These trends were also observed when species lists from published and unpublished studies of other large allopatric dichotomiine species, with a more northerly distribution, were included in the analyses.
4. The results obtained suggest that where large dichotomiine species are abundant, their efficient pre-emption of a considerable proportion of available resources drives all, or most, other fast-tunnelling species to a lower population density, thereby decreasing assemblage diversity.