A quantitative comparison of two extremes in chaparral shrub phenology

We quantitatively compared phenology and water relations of a fully deciduous shrub, Styrax officinalis, and an evergreen shrub, Arctostaphylos glauca, in shared microsites in a sandstone outcrop in southern California during a multi-year drought. Pre-dawn xylem pressure potentials, Ψ_pd, were similar for the two species during most months of 2 years, but occasional differences and watering experiment results suggest S. officinalis may have phreatophytic roots that tap water in deep rock cavities and joint traces, while A. glauca may have primarily shallow roots. Neither species varied in maximum or minimum Ψ_pd between years of very different rainfall totals. Twig elongation and leaf production of S. officinalis began earlier during spring, and its leaves matured more quickly and more synchronously than A. glauca. Leaves lived a mean of 180 days for S. officinalis and 849 days for A. glauca. Leaf life spans varied among years in both species. S. officinalis leaf senescence occurred mostly in August and September and was not discernibly related to Ψ_pd or drought avoidance. A. glauca leaf senescence occurred throughout the year, but especially coincided with leaf production. In A. glauca most senescence occurred at the beginning of a leaf cohort's third growing season, but numbers of retained older leaves increased during 4 years of drought. Timing of twig elongation and leaf and flower production appeared to be related to current rainfall, but amount of twig growth and numbers of leaves and flowers produced appeared to be related to rainfall of the previous year or years for S. officinalis and, more complexly, A. glauca. Because of an interrupted pattern of flower production, number of flowers produced by A. glauca may be responsive to rainfall amounts during two environmental periods. Morphological differences, including much higher above ground allocation, many more leaves/twig, lower allocation to stem mass, and longer duration of leaves/year in A. glauca, are probably responsible for A. glauca having >6 times more above ground biomass per plant than S. officinalis. During the multi-year drought S. officinalis changed little, indicating either superb adaptation or growth pattern rigidity, while A. glauca underwent extensive phenological and morphological changes, indicating either stress or adaptive flexibility.