Some Early Developments in Ratio Estimation

John Graunt (1662) was the first to estimate the ratio y/x where y represents the total population and x the known total number of registered births in the same areas during the preceding year. About 1765 Messance (Stephan, 1948) and Moheau (1778) published very carefully prepared estimates for France based on enumeration of population in certain districts and on the count of births, deaths and marriages as reported for the whole country. The districts from which the ratio of inhabitants to birth was determined only constituted a sample. Laplace (1786) prepared similar estimates in 1802 based on a two-stage sampling plan. Recently Hansen and Hurwitz (1943) showed that the ratio estimate (y_i/n_i)X of Y is unbiased where all x_i's are known and the n^th cluster is selected with p.p.s. More recently Hájek (1949), Lahiri (1951), Midzuno (1952) and Sen (1952) developed independently the sampling of n clusters with p.p.s to the totals of the sizes of the sample clusters S(x_i). Des Raj (1954) and Sen (1952, 1953) gave unbiased estimate of the variance of the estimator which was generally non-negative for samples with smaller probabilities. Rao and Vijayan (1977) gave an unbiased estimator which is non-negative for samples with larger probabilities. Hájek (1949) provided an almost unbiased estimator of the variance of the estimator. The paper discusses situations where Hájek's estimator of variance should be preferred to the Rao-Vijayan estimator and vice versa.