Physical Disturbance and Community Structure of Exposed and Protected Reefs: A Case Study from St. John, U.S. Virgin Islands

Major physical disturbances impacted fringing reefs at 4 to12 m depth off the south coast of St. John, at intervals of28, 14 and 12 months over a 6 year period (1985–1991).The most wave exposed habitats were dominated by the hydrocoralMillepora alcicornis and the encrusting gorgonian Erythropodiumcaribaeorum. Both of these species displayed high resistancestability in response to the 1987 bleaching event and to HurricanesGilbert (1988) and Hugo (1989). Although Hurricane Hugo wasranked as the most severe hurricane of the past century, itcaused comparatively little damage to the shallow exposed reef,illustrating that the effects of physical disturbance may notalways conform to a priori predictions based on wave exposure.This counter-intuitive result is explicable when the chronologyof disturbance is considered. For example, the shallow exposedcommunity was more heavily damaged than the protected reef byHurricane Gilbert occurring one year prior to Hurricane Hugo.Sponges and thick mats of E. caribaeorum had accumulated onthe protected reef during a 54 month period of little disturbanceand were vulnerable to disturbance by virtue of their elevationabove the substratum. These organisms were dislodged by extremewater motion generated by Hurricane Hugo. In contrast, the shallowexposed community was still recovering from Hurricane Gilbertwhen Hurricane Hugo struck. Monitored populations of two coralspecies, Agaricia agaricites and Tubastrea coccinea, declinedover the six year period, but recruitment in 1990 partiallycompensated for high mortality caused byHurricane Hugo. Therewere significant increases in the abundance of algal turf onthree out of the four study reefs (4 m exposed and protected,12 m protected) in response to the creation of patch space bythe multiple physical disturbances. This study demonstratesthe need to interpret recent disturbances in light of the historyof past disturbance on the reef.