Influence of cholesterol on bilayers of ester- and ether-linked phospholipids Permeability and 13C-nuclear magnetic resonance measurements

¹³C-NMR and permeability studies are described for sonicated vesicles of phosphatidylcholines bearing two 16-carbon saturated hydrocarbon chains with (a) one ether linkage at carbon 1 (3) or 2 of glycerol and one ester linkage at carbon 2 or 1 (3) of glycerol; (b) two ether linkages and (c) two ester linkages at carbons 1 (3) and 2 of glycerol. The results of ¹³C-NMR relaxation enhancement measurements using cholesterol enriched with ¹³C at the 4 position indicate that no significant relocation of the cholesterol molecules takes place in the bilayer when a methylene group is substituted for a carbonyl group in phosphatidylcholine. The 4-¹³C atom of cholesterol undergoes similar fast anisotropic motions in diester- and diether-phosphatidylcholine bilayers, as judged by spin-lattice relaxation time measurements in the liquid-crystalline phase; although the fast motions are unaltered, linewidth and spin-spin relaxation time measurements suggested some restriction of the slow motions of cholesterol molecules in bilayers from phosphatidylcholines containing an O-alkyl linkage at the sn-2 position instead of an acyl linkage. At temperatures above the gel to liquid-crystal phase transition, the kinetics of ionophore A23187-mediated ⁴⁵Ca²⁺ efflux from vesicles prepared from each type of phosphatidylcholine molecule were the same; the kinetics of spontaneous carboxyfluorescein diffusion from diester- and diether-phosphatidylcholine vesicles were the same, whereas mixed ether/ester phosphatidylcholine molecules gave bilayers which are less permeable. The rate constants were reduced on cholesterol incorporation into the bilayers of each type of phosphatidylcholine molecule. The reductions were not statistically significant for ⁴⁵Ca²⁺ release. The rate constants for carboxyfluorescein release were also reduced by cholesterol to the same extent in vesicles from diester-, diether-, and 1-ether-2-ester-phosphatidylcholines; however, a smaller reduction was noted in bilayers from the 1-ester-2-ether analog. These results provide further evidence that there are no highly specific requirements for ester or ether linkages in phosphatidylcholine for cholesterol to reduce bilayer permeability. This is a reflection of the fact that in both diester- and diether-phosphatidylcholine bilayers, the 4-¹³C atom of cholesterol is located in the region of the acyl carboxyl group or the glyceryl ether oxygen atom.