Generation of Cubic Membranes by Controlled Homotypic Interaction of Membrane Proteins in the Endoplasmic Reticulum

Cell membranes predominantly consist of lamellar lipid bilayers. When studied in vitro, however, many membrane lipids can exhibit non-lamellar morphologies, often with cubic symmetries. An open issue is how lipid polymorphisms influence organelle and cell shape. Here, we used controlled dimerization of artificial membrane proteins in mammalian tissue culture cells to induce an expansion of the endoplasmic reticulum (ER) with cubic symmetry. Although this observation emphasizes ER architectural plasticity, we found that the changed ER membrane became sequestered into large autophagic vacuoles, positive for the autophagy protein LC3. Autophagy may be targeting irregular membrane shapes and/or aggregated protein. We suggest that membrane morphology can be controlled in cells.The observation that simple mixtures of amphiphilic (polar) lipids and water yield a rich flora of phase structures has opened a long-standing debate as to whether such membrane polymorphisms are relevant for living organisms (1–7). Lipid bilayers with planar geometry, termed lamellar symmetry, dominate the membrane structure of cells. However, this architecture comprises only a fraction of the structures seen with in vitro lipid-water systems (7–11). The propensity to form lamellar bilayers (a property exclusive to cylindrically shaped lipids) is flanked by a continuum of lipid structures that occur in a number of exotic and probably non-physiological non-bilayer configurations (3, 12). However, certain lipids, particularly those with smaller head groups and more bulky hydrocarbon chains, can adopt bilayered non-lamellar phases called cubic phases. Here the bilayer is curved everywhere in the form of saddle shapes corresponding to an energetically favorable minimal surface of zero mean curvature (1, 7). Because a substantial number of the lipids present in biological membranes, when studied as individual pure lipids, form cubic phases (13), cubic membranes have received particular interest in cell biology.Since the application of electron microscopy (EM)³ to the study of cell ultrastructure, unusual membrane morphologies have been reported for virtually every organelle (14, 15). However, interpretation of three-dimensional structures from two-dimensional electron micrographs is not easy (16). In seminal work, Landh (17) developed the method of direct template correlative matching, a technique that unequivocally assesses the presence of cubic membranes in biological specimens (16). Cubic phases adopt mathematically well defined three-dimensional configurations whose two-dimensional analogs have been derived (4, 17). In direct template correlative matching, electron micrographs are matched to these analogs. Cubic cell membrane geometries and in vitro cubic phases of purified lipid mixtures do differ in their lattice parameters; however, such deviations are thought to relate to differences in water activity and lipid to protein ratios (10, 14, 18). Direct template correlative matching has revealed thousands of examples of cellular cubic membranes in a broad survey of electron micrographs ranging from protozoa to human cells (14, 17) and, more recently, in the mitochondria of amoeba (19) and in subcellular membrane compartments associated with severe acute respiratory syndrome virus (20). Analysis of cellular cubic membranes has also been furthered by the development of EM tomography that confirmed the presence of cubic bilayers in the mitochondrial membranes of amoeba (21, 22).Although it is now clear that cubic membranes can exist in living cells, the generation of such architecture would appear tightly regulated, as evidenced by the dominance of lamellar bilayers in biology. In this light, we examined the capability and implications of generating cubic membranes in the endoplasmic reticulum (ER) of mammalian tissue culture cells. The ER is a spatially interconnected complex consisting of two domains, the nuclear envelope and the peripheral ER (23–26). The nuclear envelope surrounds the nucleus and is composed of two continuous sheets of membranes, an inner and outer nuclear membrane connected to each other at nuclear pores. The peripheral ER constitutes a network of branching trijunctional tubules that are continuous with membrane sheet regions that occur in closer proximity to the nucleus. Recently it has been suggested that the classical morphological definition of rough ER (ribosome-studded) and smooth ER (ribosome-free) may correspond to sheet-like and tubular ER domains, respectively (27). The ER has a strong potential for cubic architectures, as demonstrated by the fact that the majority of cubic cell membranes in the EM record come from ER-derived structures (14, 17). Furthermore, ER cubic symmetries are an inducible class of organized smooth ER (OSER), a definition collectively referring to ordered smooth ER membranes (=stacked cisternae on the outer nuclear membrane, also called Karmelle (28–30), packed sinusoidal ER (31), concentric membrane whorls (30, 32–34), and arrays of crystalloid ER (35–37)). Specifically, weak homotypic interactions between membrane proteins produce both a whorled and a sinusoidal OSER phenotype (38), the latter exhibiting a cubic symmetry (16, 39).We were able to produce OSER with cubic membrane morphology via induction of homo-dimerization of artificial membrane proteins. Interestingly, the resultant cubic membrane architecture was removed from the ER system by incorporation into large autophagic vacuoles. To assess whether these cubic symmetries were favored in the absence of cellular energy, we depleted ATP. To our surprise, the cells responded by forming large domains of tubulated membrane, suggesting that a cubic symmetry was not the preferred conformation of the system. Our results suggest that whereas the endoplasmic reticulum is capable of adopting cubic symmetries, both the inherent properties of the ER system and active cellular mechanisms, such as autophagy, can tightly control their appearance.