Residues Important for Nitrate/Proton Coupling in Plant and Mammalian CLC Transporters

Members of the CLC gene family either function as chloride channels or as anion/proton exchangers. The plant AtClC-a uses the pH gradient across the vacuolar membrane to accumulate the nutrient in this organelle. When AtClC-a was expressed in Xenopus oocytes, it mediated exchange and less efficiently mediated Cl^–/H⁺ exchange. Mutating the “gating glutamate” Glu-203 to alanine resulted in an uncoupled anion conductance that was larger for Cl^– than . Replacing the “proton glutamate” Glu-270 by alanine abolished currents. These could be restored by the uncoupling E203A mutation. Whereas mammalian endosomal ClC-4 and ClC-5 mediate stoichiometrically coupled 2Cl^–/H⁺ exchange, their transport is largely uncoupled from protons. By contrast, the AtClC-a-mediated accumulation in plant vacuoles requires tight coupling. Comparison of AtClC-a and ClC-5 sequences identified a proline in AtClC-a that is replaced by serine in all mammalian CLC isoforms. When this proline was mutated to serine (P160S), Cl^–/H⁺ exchange of AtClC-a proceeded as efficiently as exchange, suggesting a role of this residue in exchange. Indeed, when the corresponding serine of ClC-5 was replaced by proline, this Cl^–/H⁺ exchanger gained efficient coupling. When inserted into the model Torpedo chloride channel ClC-0, the equivalent mutation increased nitrate relative to chloride conductance. Hence, proline in the CLC pore signature sequence is important for exchange and conductance both in plants and mammals. Gating and proton glutamates play similar roles in bacterial, plant, and mammalian CLC anion/proton exchangers.CLC proteins are found in all phyla from bacteria to humans and either mediate electrogenic anion/proton exchange or function as chloride channels (1). In mammals, the roles of plasma membrane CLC Cl^– channels include transepithelial transport (2–5) and control of muscle excitability (6), whereas vesicular CLC exchangers may facilitate endocytosis (7) and lysosomal function (8–10) by electrically shunting vesicular proton pump currents (11). In the plant Arabidopsis thaliana, there are seven CLC isoforms (AtClC-a–AtClC-g)² (12–15), which may mostly reside in intracellular membranes. AtClC-a uses the pH gradient across the vacuolar membrane to transport the nutrient nitrate into that organelle (16). This secondary active transport requires a tightly coupled exchange. Astonishingly, however, mammalian ClC-4 and -5 and bacterial EcClC-1 (one of the two CLC isoforms in Escherichia coli) display tightly coupled Cl^–/H⁺ exchange, but anion flux is largely uncoupled from H⁺ when is transported (17–21). The lack of appropriate expression systems for plant CLC transporters (12) has so far impeded structure-function analysis that may shed light on the ability of AtClC-a to perform efficient exchange. This dearth of data contrasts with the extensive mutagenesis work performed with CLC proteins from animals and bacteria.The crystal structure of bacterial CLC homologues (22, 23) and the investigation of mutants (17, 19–21, 24–29) have yielded important insights into their structure and function. CLC proteins form dimers with two largely independent permeation pathways (22, 25, 30, 31). Each of the monomers displays two anion binding sites (22). A third binding site is observed when a certain key glutamate residue, which is located halfway in the permeation pathway of almost all CLC proteins, is mutated to alanine (23). Mutating this gating glutamate in CLC Cl^– channels strongly affects or even completely suppresses single pore gating (23), whereas CLC exchangers are transformed by such mutations into pure anion conductances that are not coupled to proton transport (17, 19, 20). Another key glutamate, located at the cytoplasmic surface of the CLC monomer, seems to be a hallmark of CLC anion/proton exchangers. Mutating this proton glutamate to nontitratable amino acids uncouples anion transport from protons in the bacterial EcClC-1 protein (27) but seems to abolish transport altogether in mammalian ClC-4 and -5 (21). In those latter proteins, anion transport could be restored by additionally introducing an uncoupling mutation at the gating glutamate (21).The functional complementation by AtClC-c and -d (12, 32) of growth phenotypes of a yeast strain deleted for the single yeast CLC Gef1 (33) suggested that these plant CLC proteins function in anion transport but could not reveal details of their biophysical properties. We report here the first functional expression of a plant CLC in animal cells. Expression of wild-type (WT) and mutant AtClC-a in Xenopus oocytes indicate a general role of gating and proton glutamate residues in anion/proton coupling across different isoforms and species. We identified a proline in the CLC signature sequence of AtClC-a that plays a crucial role in exchange. Mutating it to serine, the residue present in mammalian CLC proteins at this position, rendered AtClC-a Cl^–/H⁺ exchange as efficient as exchange. Conversely, changing the corresponding serine of ClC-5 to proline converted it into an efficient exchanger. When proline replaced the critical serine in Torpedo ClC-0, the relative conductance of this model Cl^– channel was drastically increased, and “fast” protopore gating was slowed.