Biological properties of necrotic and non-necrotic strains of bean yellow mosaic virus in cool season grain legumes

A collection of 51 bean yellow mosaic virus (BYMV) isolates was transmitted from infected Trifolium subterraneum (subterranean clover) to Lupinus angustifolius (narrow‐leafed lupin) by Myzus persicae (green peach aphid). Depending on isolate and L. angiistifolius genotype used, two distinct responses developed in L. angustifolius plants, either systemic necrosis and plant death or non‐necrotic reactions of varying severity. Ten isolates caused necrosis and plant death in cv. Danja. However, when nine of these were inoculated to breeding line 90L423‐07‐13, seven induced non‐necrotic reactions, while two caused necrosis and plant death. Thirty seven isolates always produced non‐necrotic reactions regardless of genotype of L. angustifolius inoculated. Non‐necrotic and necrotic isolates originally came both from lupins and other species, and the non‐necrotic isolates were no less efficiently transmitted by M. persicae than the necrotic ones. When one isolate of each type was inoculated together to T. subterraneum and nine months later this culture was used as an acquisition source for aphid transmission to L. angustifolius, only the necrotic type was detected. Previous infection of L. angustifolius plants with a non necrolic isolate prevented subsequent infection by a necrotic one. All necrotic and non‐necrotic isolates reacted with BYMV antiserum in ELISA but only two cross‐reacted with antiserum to clover yellow vein virus (CYVV). When selected necrotic and non‐necrotic isolates were inoculated to differential hosts, all behaved like BYMV and not CYVV. When three isolates of each type were transmitted to 11 other cool season grain legume species, except in Cicer arietinum (chickpea), there were no necrotic reactions, but symptom severity varied with the isolate and species inoculated. The two isolates that caused necrosis in C. arietinum did not do so in L. angustifolius. The six isolates from Vicia faba (faba bean) all caused non‐necrotic reactions in L. angustifolius cv. Danja and 90L423‐07‐13. These and two necrotic isolates readily infected five genotypes of V. faba always causing severe symptoms. However, three non‐necrotic isolates from L. angustifolius and a further necrotic isolate were poorly infectious on V. faba in which they generally induced mild symptoms. These results show that at least three strain groups of BYMV can be distinguished by their reactions in different L. angustifolius genotypes, one causing necrosis and death in cv. Danja and 90L423‐07‐13, one causing necrosis and death in Danja but not 90L423‐07‐13, and one causing non‐nccrotic reactions in both. These strain groups could not be distinguished when representative necrotic and non‐necrotic isolates were inoculated to other grain legume species. However, inoculation to V. faba distinguished two other BYMV strain groupings differing in severity of symptoms and ability to infect this species.